Restoring What Wasn’t Lost: How Mormonism Rebuilt the System Jesus Already Replaced

In this episode, we compare the church in the book of Acts with the church Joseph Smith built—showing how the LDS ‘restoration’ actually rebuilds the hierarchy, temples, and priesthoods Jesus fulfilled and the Reformers fought to remove. It’s not a return to the New Testament but a reversal of the freedom Christ brought.

--

The Unveiling Mormonism podcast pulls back the curtain on Mormon history, culture and doctrine. Join us for new episodes every Monday.

Find resources to talk about these episodes at pursueGOD.org/mormonism.

Help others go "full circle" as a follower of Jesus through our 12-week Pursuit series.

Click here to learn more about how to use these resources at home, with a small group, or in a one-on-one discipleship relationship.

Got questions or want to leave a note? Email us at podcast@pursueGOD.org.

Donate Now

--

SUMMARY

Latter-day Saints teach that after the apostles died, the church fell into total apostasy—losing authority, truth, and the gospel—and that Joseph Smith “restored” the original church in 1830.

But when we compare the Bible, early church history, and the medieval church, a clear pattern emerges: the LDS system doesn’t look like the church in the book of Acts. It looks like the institutional system that developed centuries later.

This episode walks through that history and shows why Mormonism isn’t a restoration of the New Testament—it’s a rebuilding of the very system Jesus fulfilled and the Reformers worked to correct.

1. What the Early Church Actually Looked Like (Book of Acts)

• No temples
• No priestly hierarchy
• No prophet-president
• No exclusive priesthood lineage
• Believers met in homes, prayed, broke bread, and studied Scripture
• Leadership was shared among elders/pastors
• Every believer was a priest (1 Peter 2)
• Access to God came directly through Jesus, not through mediators

Bottom line: The early church was simple, Spirit-led, and centered entirely on Jesus.

2. How the Church Drifted in the Middle Ages

By the 4th century, especially after Constantine:

• The church became tied to political power
• Bishops became rulers
• Priests acted as mediators
• Salvation was tied to rituals and sacraments
• A single head (the Pope) claimed God-given authority

This system dominated medieval Christianity and buried the gospel under layers of tradition and hierarchy.

3. The Reformation: Returning to Scripture

Luther, Calvin, Zwingli, and the Anabaptists didn’t invent a new church.

They removed the medieval layers and returned to:

• Scripture alone
• Grace alone
• Christ alone
• Faith alone

Real renewal happens when ordinary believers open the Bible again.

4. Joseph Smith Recreates the Medieval System

Despite claiming to “restore” the church, Joseph Smith introduced:

• A layered priesthood (Aaronic & Melchizedek)
• A prophet-president with final authority
• Temple rituals and restricted access
• Ordinances required for salvation
• Centralized headquarters claiming exclusive truth

This mirrors the medieval Catholic model, not the church in Acts.

5. The LDS Temple: The Most Striking Irony

Jesus ended the temple system:

• The veil tore
• Jesus became the final High Priest
• The church became the temple (Ephesians 2)
• The Spirit lives in every believer

The early church never rebuilt temples or practiced proxy work for the dead.

The LDS Church brings back the very system the New Testament declares obsolete.

6. The Pattern in Real Church History

Across movements—the Hussites, Reformers, Moravians, Anabaptists, Puritans—renewal always happens the same way:

• By returning to the Bible
• By preaching the gospel
• By centering everything on Jesus

No new prophets.

No restored priesthood.

No rebuilt temple.

No extra books or hierarchy.

Just Scripture, Christ, and the Spirit.

THE MAIN POINT

Jesus didn’t leave His church.

The gospel was never lost.

The Holy Spirit never disappeared.

The early church didn’t need to be restored—because Christ kept His promise to build it.

The LDS restoration story isn’t a recovery of the New Testament church.

It’s a reversal—a return to the very structures Jesus fulfilled and the Reformers removed.