539: Wicked Witches (from "Mean Girl Murders")
SOMETHING WICKED THIS WAY COMES! When Misty makes a new friend, Jenny, at work, she’s roped into a web of…strangeness when Jenny’s “guardian” (yeah, we have questions too) Irina. Irina suggests the th...
5 Nov 54min
538: Kill. Bury. Print.
WE ARE TOTAL NERDS FOR LOCAL NEWSPAPERS! Come nerd out with us about this TRULY UNBELIVABLE STORY. In the small town of Idabel, Oklahoma, a family-run newspaper begins investigating allegations of cor...
3 Nov 1h 27min
537: Fertility Fraud (from "Betrayal")
OMG PATRICK'S FAVORITE PODCAST IS NOW A HULU SHOW! OK, deep breaths! Meet Tina, just, you know, ANOTHER BAD ASS WOMAN ABOUT TO HAVE HER LIFE TURNED UPSIDE DOWN BY SOME AWFUL GUY! And so enter, Neil, ...
29 Okt 1h 2min
536: Trainwreck: Storm Area 51 Part 2
Shit got real REAL fast when the FBI came knock knock knocking on Matty's door. They let him know: Anyone gets hurt or dies at this thing, it's your ass, kid. Does Matty take this opportunity to, you ...
27 Okt 50min
535: Trainwreck: Storm Area 51 Part 1
Meet Matty, the self-described "twenty-year-old loser working at the vape kiosk in the mall." In 2019, bored and sort of as a joke, he made a post on his Facebook page - "shitposting" - encouraging hi...
20 Okt 53min
534: What the Neighbors Saw (from "48 Hours")
In 2013, Gary Herpst left his wife and son and went missing. But... they didn't seem to mind all that much and only RELUCTANTLY filed a missing person report for him. Turns out this guy was a reeeee...
15 Okt 46min
533: Worst Ex Ever: Primetime Predator
Fam, we are here for the sisterhood and solidarity today! Both Kristen and Sabrina were victims of Geoffrey's controlling and abusive behavior, but thankfully they both come through to the horrors to...
13 Okt 1h 11min
532: Mommy's Little Helper (from "Mother, May I Murder?")
In April 2012, 61-year-old Mark Staudte died on the floor of his home. When the authorities arrived, his wife, Diane, seemed.. .unphased. And the kids were playing video games in the living room. It w...
8 Okt 53min
