Nancy Guthrie: “Gone in the Night” | MURDERISH Ep. 207

A faint breeze swept through the Catalina Foothills, skittering specks of desert sand across North Campbell Avenue, a seven-mile artery that climbs from the gates of the University of Arizona to the jagged base of the Santa Catalina Mountains. Just after 1:45 AM on February 1st, 2026 in the Catalina Foothills most residents of the wealthy enclave north of Tucson had long since gone to bed. Among them Nancy Guthrie, mother of Today show anchor, Savannah Guthrie. Lying still in a deep slumber, the 84-year-old didn’t notice when the lights on her home router suddenly flipped from a steady blue to blinking red, a subtle sign that her connection to the outside world had been severed. Nor did she see the push notification on her silenced cellphone alerting her that the doorbell camera had detected motion. By the time she realized something was wrong, it was already too late. As of the date of this recording, it’s been nearly two months since the beloved matriarch was abducted. Despite a million-dollar reward, around-the-clock press coverage, and the combined efforts of the FBI and local authorities, there remains no clear evidence of where she might be or who took her. Subscribe to Jami’s YouTube channel @JamiOnAir: https://www.youtube.com/@jamionair Follow Jami @JamiOnAir on Instagram and TikTok. Sponsors Laundry Sauce: Visit laundrysauce.com and use code MURDERISH for 20% off your order. Kikoff: Visit getkikoff.com/MURDERISH to get your first month for as little as $1. Factor: Visit factormeals.com/murderish50off and use code murderish50off to get 50% off & free breakfast for a year. Shopify: Visit shopify.com/murderish to sign up for a $1/month trial. Dirty Money Moves: Women in White Collar Crime - Listen on Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/dirty-money-moves-women-in-white-collar-crime/id1619521092. Research and writing by: K. Brant. Nancy Guthrie case tip line: 1 (800) CALL-FBI or 1 (800) 225-5324. A $1 million reward is currently offered by the family for information leading to her recovery, alongside a separate $100,000 reward from the FBI. Tips can be submitted anonymously. Want to advertise on this show? We’ve partnered with Cloud10 Media to handle our advertising requests. If you’re interested in advertising on MURDERISH, please send an email to Sahiba Krieger sahiba@cloud10.fm and copy jami@murderish.com. Visit Murderish.com to learn more about the podcast and Creator/Host, Jami, and to view a list of sources for this episode. Listening to this podcast doesn’t make you a murderer, it just means you’re murder..ish. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices