63: Nietzsche Contra Socialism

63: Nietzsche Contra Socialism

Today, we look at the other side of the coin. Nietzsche's critique of capitalism is in fact inextricably bound to his critique of socialism. What he finds beneath both approaches to managing human economic affairs is the utilitarian value structure and the view of the human being as homo economicus. Socialism, rather than the solution to capitalism, is the necessary end of the same internal logic, and further seeks to cut off avenues for man's will to power as we labor under the mistaken assumption that by reducing suffering we will maximize pleasure. The closer we proceed to an idealized, painless society, the more our individuality is smoothed over. Increasingly, the only avenue for the expression of power is through the only remaining hierarchical structure: the state. Originally created by mankind to be a means, the state becomes the ends. In a twisted irony, the likes of the socialists and anarchists - who desire above all for a classless, stateless society - bring forth an all-powerful state as the means of doing this, and become consumed by it.

A neat aspect of the episode order here is that we're covering Nietzsche's political thought in a rough chronology - meaning that, while we might jump around from place to place, and occasionally grab a quote from Beyond Good & Evil, we're moving from the second and third book of Human, All Too Human into covering a lot more material from Daybreak, while still drawing on sources from elsewhere in the middle period. The next episode - Nietzsche's critique of fascism - covers around the same period, in terms of the letters and statements he made about Wagner and Elisabeth during his breaks with them, in addition to drawing on passages from throughout his work.

Ian Wright's article, "Capital as a Real God": https://ianwrightsite.wordpress.com/2020/09/03/marx-on-capital-as-a-real-god-2/

Thomas Brobjer's studies showing that Nietzsche knew Marx: https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.1515/9783110170740.298/html

My essay on Star Trek: https://untimely-reflections.blogspot.com/2021/05/neverending-frontier-star-treks.html

Avsnitt(229)

The Gay Science #18 (IV.299-310)

The Gay Science #18 (IV.299-310)

Continuing with our readthrough of The Gay Science, book number IV.

9 Sep 2h 11min

The Gay Science #17 (IV.289-298)

The Gay Science #17 (IV.289-298)

Embark, philosophers! Nietzsche hopes for the discovery of many new suns - many new suns - by the philosophical explorers of future ages. For what is needful is that man may learn to be satisfied with himself. Episode art: Fresh Breeze of Sandy Hook, 1860 by William Bradford

3 Sep 2h 8min

Untimely Reflections #37: PF Jung - Enlightened Centrism

Untimely Reflections #37: PF Jung - Enlightened Centrism

PF Jung's channel: https://www.youtube.com/@PFJungIf politics is in some sense determined by our psychological temperament, then from an evolutionary standpoint, perhaps there is social value to both the left and right wing perspectives. And yet, centrism remains a dirty word in online discourse, connoting a type of establishment position that favors the status quo. Pf Jung joins me to discuss his philosophy of "radical enlightened centrism", which opposes the status quo while drawing on ideas from both fringes. Also, a correction: at one point in the conversation I claim that Australia has a mandatory civil service, but this is actually incorrect. I got this confused because of a conversation I recalled between myself, an Australian and a German, in which we talked about mandatory civil service (which Germany has) and mandatory voting (which Australia has), but Australia does not have mandatory civil service.

26 Aug 1h 27min

The Gay Science #16 (IV.276-288)

The Gay Science #16 (IV.276-288)

Continuing with The Gay Science, and beginning with book IV, "Sanctus Januarius". Here, we encounter some of the most famous aphorisms: For the New Year, Preparatory Men ("Live Dangerously!") and Excelsior. Exciting times!Episode art: View of Genoa under the Snow - Eugenio Olivari (1882-1917)

19 Aug 1h 56min

120: Erich Heller, The Disinherited Mind, pt 2 - Burckhardt, Nietzsche & History

120: Erich Heller, The Disinherited Mind, pt 2 - Burckhardt, Nietzsche & History

The conclusion of our two-parter on Erich Heller, and the conclusion to season five! We discuss Nietzsche's friendship with Jacob Burckhardt, and how Burckhardt's view of history can inform our understanding of Nietzsche's divergence from him. We also consider Goethe's four ages of intellectual culture, and Nietzsche's echo of Goethe in his history of European nihilism, and how he comes to differ from Goethe, Schopenhauer and all his influences in his proclamations about history, in which the Overman shall transcend the cyclical, unchanging stagnation of human history by changing the nature of man himself. Finally, we consider what the hazard of modern poetry means for us in the present day, what each figure's answer to this divorce between symbol & real means, whether they succeeded or not, and what we can learn from them.

12 Aug 1h 44min

119: Erich Heller, The Disinherited Mind, pt 1 - Goethe, Schiller & The Symbol

119: Erich Heller, The Disinherited Mind, pt 1 - Goethe, Schiller & The Symbol

Something happened to the human mind around the birth of modernity: the divorce of reality and the symbol. Once unified in eucharist, the symbolic and the real are now separate spheres of the human mind, and while it initially seemed that art and science might benefit by this separation, in the long run, both have ended up poorer thereby. In this episode, the two-part finale of season five, we will discuss Luther & Zwingli, and their dispute about the holy communion; Goethe & Schiller and their argument about the difference between the idea and the experience; and Goethe's avoidance of tragedy and what this says about the "hazard of modern poetry".

5 Aug 1h 39min

Q&A #12

Q&A #12

Additional episode will release tomorrow. Erich Heller two-parter starts next week for the season finale!

29 Juli 2h 24min

118: Max Horkheimer & Theodore Adorno - Dialectic of Enlightenment, Part 2

118: Max Horkheimer & Theodore Adorno - Dialectic of Enlightenment, Part 2

An exploration of the chapter on Homer's Odyssey and on De Sade's Juliette. How enlightenment and the rationality of domination is contained in the Odyssey, and how the self-undoing of enlightenment morality is contained in Juliette.

21 Juli 1h 47min

Populärt inom Samhälle & Kultur

podme-dokumentar
en-mork-historia
svenska-fall
p3-dokumentar
nemo-moter-en-van
skaringer-nessvold
creepypodden-med-jack-werner
killradet
rattsfallen
p1-dokumentar
flashback-forever
hor-har
vad-blir-det-for-mord
historiska-brott
kod-katastrof
dialogiskt
sanna-berattelser
rysarpodden
p3-historia
fallen-som-forfoljer