Convicted on Bite Mark Evidence P5: The Charles McCrory Case

Convicted on Bite Mark Evidence P5: The Charles McCrory Case

In 1985, Charles McCrory found his wife, Julie Bonds, brutally murdered in their Andalusia, Alabama, home. Just two small marks on her arm—misrepresented in court as a definitive “bite mark”—became the sole forensic evidence used to convict him for her murder.


A forensic odontologist, famed for testifying at Ted Bundy’s trial, claimed the impressions matched McCrory’s like a fingerprint. Yet decades later, that same expert fully recanted the testimony, acknowledging the scientific consensus now recognises bite mark evidence as unreliable “junk science”.


With no blood, no DNA, and hair in the victim’s hand that didn’t match McCrory’s, his conviction rested entirely on this flawed forensic interpretation. Over 40 years later, even as two independent forensic dentists testified that the so called bite mark was never human, Alabama courts repeatedly denied him a new trial, judging that his lengthy imprisonment still stood, and that procedural hurdles outweighed modern science


In July 2024, the U.S. Supreme Court refused to review his case. Justice Sotomayor warned that wrongful convictions like his, based on “faulty science,” are startlingly common and urged state and federal lawmakers to enact stronger safeguards to prevent miscarriages of justice.

EARLY AND AD FREE ACCESS: for as little as $1.69 a week!


Apple + HERE


Patreon and find us on Facebook here.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Avsnitt(363)

'not to be reduced by credits' - Tariq Maqbool

'not to be reduced by credits' - Tariq Maqbool

After twenty-three years, a last-minute act of clemency from a departing New Jersey governor changed everything for Tariq MaQbool. 150 years became 45, Maximum security became lower. However inside th...

11 Mars 22min

What the attorney thinks - John Spirko

What the attorney thinks - John Spirko

We just wrapped up the story of John Spirko, a man who's spent over 40 years in prison for a murder that put him on death row, a murder he's always maintained he's innocent of, even though he was the ...

9 Mars 23min

He lied his way onto Death Row - John Spirko P5

He lied his way onto Death Row - John Spirko P5

In 1982, postmistress Betty Jane Mottinger was abducted from her one-room post office in Elgin, Ohio — a town of fifty people and murdered.Six weeks later, John Spirko, a career criminal with a talent...

4 Mars 31min

He lied his way onto Death Row - John Spirko P4

He lied his way onto Death Row - John Spirko P4

In 1982, postmistress Betty Jane Mottinger was abducted from her one-room post office in Elgin, Ohio — a town of fifty people and murdered.Six weeks later, John Spirko, a career criminal with a talent...

2 Mars 31min

He lied his way onto Death Row - John Spirko P3

He lied his way onto Death Row - John Spirko P3

In 1982, postmistress Betty Jane Mottinger was abducted from her one-room post office in Elgin, Ohio — a town of fifty people and murdered.Six weeks later, John Spirko, a career criminal with a talent...

25 Feb 35min

He lied his way onto Death Row - John Spirko P2

He lied his way onto Death Row - John Spirko P2

In 1982, postmistress Betty Jane Mottinger was abducted from her one-room post office in Elgin, Ohio — a town of fifty people and murdered. Six weeks later, John Spirko, a career criminal with a talen...

23 Feb 32min

He lied his way onto Death Row - John Spirko P1

He lied his way onto Death Row - John Spirko P1

In 1982, postmistress Betty Jane Mottinger was abducted from her one-room post office in Elgin, Ohio — a town of fifty people and murdered. Six weeks later, John Spirko, a career criminal with a talen...

18 Feb 32min

OUT NOW! What I Survived

OUT NOW! What I Survived

What I Survived explores the extraordinary true stories of people who survived the unthinkable. Each story takes you back to who these people were before everything changed, then inside the moment the...

17 Feb 3min

Populärt inom True Crime

podme-dokumentar
rattegangspodden
podme-crime
fallen-jag-aldrig-glommer
svenska-fall
aftonbladet-krim
en-mork-historia
krimrummet
svenska-mordhistorier
rss-svenska-fall-podcast
forhorsrummet
seriemordarpodden
p3-krim
makabra-mord
rss-krimstad
rss-valdet-krim
infor-ratta
alskade-psykopat
spoktimmen
massmordarpodden