Maria Jimena Clavel Vazquez - Naturalizing Heidegger (Against his Will)
BSP Podcast1 Elo 2018

Maria Jimena Clavel Vazquez - Naturalizing Heidegger (Against his Will)

This is one of the papers from our 2017 Annual Conference, the Future of Phenomenology. Information and the full conference booklet can be found at www.britishphenomenology.org.uk

The question regarding the pertinence of using Heidegger’s analytic of Dasein as a guide for empirical research arises from contemporary attempts to bring Heideggerian phenomenology and cognitive science together. I will focus on one of the main figures behind these attempts, Hubert Dreyfus. I will start by showing that Dreyfus argues in favour of the idea that Heideggerian phenomenology can be naturalized and made continuous with scientific research on the basis of two implicit premises: (a) the interpretation of the analytic of Dasein as a regional ontology; and (b) an account of the relation between phenomenology and science as a relation that holds between two disciplines of the same kind, but that stand at different levels. The aim of this paper is to show that it is not possible to defend these premises on Heideggerian grounds. I will do so by analysing Heidegger’s considerations regarding anthropology, psychology, and biology, and their difference with the analytic of Dasein. I will argue that the main difference can be found in Heidegger’s definition of phenomenological concepts (i.e. formal indications). Finally, I will argue that, although Dreyfus fails to take into account the nature of phenomenological concepts as a relevant methodological matter, his project of naturalization raises a valid concern regarding the possibility of taking Heidegger’s ontology back to a relation with the ontic sciences.

Tämä jakso on lisätty Podme-palveluun avoimen RSS-syötteen kautta eikä se ole Podmen omaa tuotantoa. Siksi jakso saattaa sisältää mainontaa.

Jaksot(224)

Emily Hughes - Boredom, static-time and alienation during lockdown

Emily Hughes - Boredom, static-time and alienation during lockdown

Season 8 concludes with a recording from our 2021 annual conference, The Future as a Present Concern.   This episode features a presentation from Emily Hughes   Abstract: In this paper I interpret th...

17 Kesä 18min

Alessandro Anzà - Transgenerational Responsibility and Phenomenology of Revolution. The Future as a Present Challenge to Education

Alessandro Anzà - Transgenerational Responsibility and Phenomenology of Revolution. The Future as a Present Challenge to Education

Season 8 continues with a recording from our 2021 annual conference, The Future as a Present Concern.   This episode features a presentation from Alessandro Anzà   Abstract: Before becoming a subject...

15 Kesä 24min

Ileana Bortun - Witnessing the Future. A Temporal Perspective on Arendt’s Political Judgment

Ileana Bortun - Witnessing the Future. A Temporal Perspective on Arendt’s Political Judgment

Season 8 continues with a recording from our 2021 annual conference, The Future as a Present Concern.   This episode features a presentation from Ileana Bortun   Abstract: I approach the theme of the...

12 Kesä 23min

David Deamer - Polysemous futurity in the cinematics of Cloud Atlas and Nietzsche’s Beyond Good and Evil

David Deamer - Polysemous futurity in the cinematics of Cloud Atlas and Nietzsche’s Beyond Good and Evil

Season 8 continues with a recording from our 2021 annual conference, The Future as a Present Concern.   This episode features a presentation from David Deamer   Abstract: Luisa Rey is reading the let...

10 Kesä 27min

J. Reese Faust - Writing a New Flesh of the World: Merleau-Ponty and Fanon on the Ethics of Futurity

J. Reese Faust - Writing a New Flesh of the World: Merleau-Ponty and Fanon on the Ethics of Futurity

Season 8 continues with a recording from our 2021 annual conference, The Future as a Present Concern.   This episode features a presentation from J. Reese Faust   Abstract: Frantz Fanon closes his tw...

8 Kesä 22min

Isabel Rocamora - In Shock and Diffidence: Imaging an Ethics of the Earth with Heidegger (a practitioner approach to climate emergency in the Scottish Highlands and Islands)

Isabel Rocamora - In Shock and Diffidence: Imaging an Ethics of the Earth with Heidegger (a practitioner approach to climate emergency in the Scottish Highlands and Islands)

Season 8 continues with a recording from our 2021 annual conference, The Future as a Present Concern.   This episode features a presentation from Isabel Rocamora   Abstract: My current moving image p...

5 Kesä 19min

Aanastasios Dimopoulos - Tacit knowledge and the formation of clinical expertise in mental healthcare; the “brave new world” of remote consultations and the future of mental healthcare

Aanastasios Dimopoulos - Tacit knowledge and the formation of clinical expertise in mental healthcare; the “brave new world” of remote consultations and the future of mental healthcare

Season 8 continues with a recording from our 2021 annual conference, The Future as a Present Concern.   This episode features a presentation from Aanastasios Dimopoulos   Abstract: Among the various ...

3 Kesä 17min

Tomás Lally - The Present as a Future Concern

Tomás Lally - The Present as a Future Concern

Season 8 continues with a recording from our 2021 annual conference, The Future as a Present Concern.   This episode features a presentation from Tomás Lally   Abstract: In this paper I want to flip ...

1 Kesä 25min

Suosittua kategoriassa Yhteiskunta

olipa-kerran-otsikko
seitseman
siita-on-vaikea-puhua
hupiklubi
i-dont-like-mondays
sita
antin-palautepalvelu
poks
ihme-ja-kumma
uutiscast
kaksi-aitia
mamma-mia
gogin-ja-janin-maailmanhistoria
yopuolen-tarinoita-2
kolme-kaannekohtaa
rss-palmujen-varjoissa
rss-haudattu
aikalisa
kummitusjuttuja
meidan-pitais-puhua