What Mickey Stines' Mental Illness Filing Is Really About

What Mickey Stines' Mental Illness Filing Is Really About

New filing just dropped in the Mickey Stines case, and it raises more questions than it answers. The former Letcher County sheriff charged with murdering Judge Kevin Mullins is asking a court to declare him ineligible for the death penalty based on serious mental illness or intellectual disability. His attorneys cite Kentucky's 2022 statute barring execution for defendants with qualifying conditions. But the motion names no diagnosis, attaches no medical documentation, and offers no specifics about what condition Stines allegedly has.

Kentucky law requires one of four diagnoses — schizophrenia, schizoaffective disorder, bipolar disorder, or delusional disorder — with a documented history and active symptoms at the time of the offense. The only time this law has ever been applied in a Kentucky courtroom, the defendant had a lifetime of institutional records and expert consensus backing the claim. The judge called it "not a close case."

We examine whether Stines can meet that bar. The defense has witness testimony describing paranoid behavior, a jail evaluation noting active psychosis days after the shooting, and Stines' own claims about California encephalitis. But the prosecution has the surveillance video, medical records where Stines denied any mental health symptoms the day before the killing, and the fact that no qualifying diagnosis has been made public. Plus, a sealed psychiatric evaluation from July 2025 that the defense hasn't been able to get into the record.

Is this a real mental health claim or a strategic play from a defense team running out of options? We break down the law, the precedent, and the evidence.

#MickeyStines #KevinMullins #TrueCrimeToday #KentuckyLaw #DeathPenalty #InsanityDefense #LetcherCounty #MentalIllnessDefense #CourthouseShooting #TrueCrime

Join Our SubStack For AD-FREE ADVANCE EPISODES & EXTRAS!: https://hiddenkillers.substack.com/

Want to comment and watch this podcast as a video? Check out our YouTube Channel. https://www.youtube.com/@hiddenkillerspod

Instagram https://www.instagram.com/hiddenkillerspod/
Facebook https://www.facebook.com/hiddenkillerspod/
Tik-Tok https://www.tiktok.com/@hiddenkillerspod
X Twitter https://x.com/TrueCrimePod

Listen Ad-Free On Apple Podcasts Here: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/true-crime-today-premium-plus-ad-free-advance-episode/id1705422872

This publication contains commentary and opinion based on publicly available information. All individuals are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. Nothing published here should be taken as a statement of fact, health or legal advice.

Jaksot(500)

Nancy Guthrie: The Most Important Person in This Case Isn't on That Porch

Nancy Guthrie: The Most Important Person in This Case Isn't on That Porch

The man on the porch followed a forensic checklist. He covered his face, his hands, his body. Someone made sure he did. But nobody told him about the camera six inches from the front door. We asked Ro...

12 Helmi 19min

Nancy Guthrie News: Gloves Recovered, FBI Deploys Hostage Rescue Team

Nancy Guthrie News: Gloves Recovered, FBI Deploys Hostage Rescue Team

The search for Nancy Guthrie entered its twelfth day with the recovery of the case's first significant physical evidence and the deployment of the FBI's elite tactical unit to Tucson.FBI agents search...

12 Helmi 19min

Nancy Guthrie: We Asked the FBI's Former Behavioral Chief What This Video Really Shows

Nancy Guthrie: We Asked the FBI's Former Behavioral Chief What This Video Really Shows

The FBI released the surveillance footage. We brought it to the man who ran the FBI's Behavioral Analysis Program and asked him what he sees.Robin Dreeke spent 21 years at the FBI specializing in coun...

12 Helmi 23min

The Reiners' Addiction to Hope: How Love Became a Death Sentence

The Reiners' Addiction to Hope: How Love Became a Death Sentence

Every parent of an addict runs the same equation — if I find the right variable, the answer changes. The right rehab. The right therapist. The right diagnosis. The right medication. Rob and Michele Re...

12 Helmi 21min

Bob Motta on Guthrie and Murdaugh: A Defense Attorney Reads Between the Lines on Both Cases

Bob Motta on Guthrie and Murdaugh: A Defense Attorney Reads Between the Lines on Both Cases

Two of the biggest cases in the country. One defense attorney who sees what the public does not. Criminal defense attorney Bob Motta joins True Crime Today to break down the Nancy Guthrie investigatio...

12 Helmi 59min

Caneiro Defense Begins: Character Witnesses, a Crying Daughter, and the Uninvestigated Brother

Caneiro Defense Begins: Character Witnesses, a Crying Daughter, and the Uninvestigated Brother

After fifteen days and four weeks of prosecution evidence, the state has rested in the Paul Caneiro quadruple murder trial in Monmouth County, New Jersey. The case they built is anchored in forensic e...

12 Helmi 15min

Alex Murdaugh: Why the AG's Office May Not Retry Even If the Conviction Falls

Alex Murdaugh: Why the AG's Office May Not Retry Even If the Conviction Falls

The South Carolina Supreme Court hears oral arguments Wednesday on Alex Murdaugh's appeal — and criminal defense attorney Bob Motta says the question nobody wants to ask is whether the state even retr...

11 Helmi 13min

Nancy Guthrie: Empty Wallet, Dead Deadlines — The Ransom Was Never Real

Nancy Guthrie: Empty Wallet, Dead Deadlines — The Ransom Was Never Real

The ransom narrative in the Nancy Guthrie case has collapsed. Both deadlines passed. The Bitcoin wallet listed in the demand — six million dollars — has never recorded a single transaction. The Guthri...

11 Helmi 17min

Suosittua kategoriassa Politiikka ja uutiset

aikalisa
rss-ootsa-kuullut-tasta
tervo-halme
ootsa-kuullut-tasta-2
politiikan-puskaradio
rss-podme-livebox
et-sa-noin-voi-sanoo-esittaa
otetaan-yhdet
rss-asiastudio
rikosmyytit
viisupodi
rss-vaalirankkurit-podcast
rss-mina-ukkola
the-ulkopolitist
radio-antro
io-techin-tekniikkapodcast
popcorn-with-esko
rss-polikulaari-humanisti-vastaa-ja-muut-ts-podcastit
rss-merja-mahkan-rahat
rss-50100-podcast