This Supreme Court ruling needs a renovation: Gerard Kennedy & Geoffrey Sigalet

This Supreme Court ruling needs a renovation: Gerard Kennedy & Geoffrey Sigalet

There’s a growing debate in Canada about balancing the relationship between courts and legislatures.

For nearly four decades, one Supreme Court ruling has loomed large in shaping an aspect of this debate: how conflicts between rights – and their limitations – are determined in Canada.

That case – R v Oakes, decided in 1986 – gave Canadian jurisprudence the famous “Oakes test,” which courts still use to assess whether limits on Charter rights are justified.

The test is widely cited. But critics argue it’s become confusing, unpredictable, and undermines the historic power legislatures are meant to share in the construction of rights.

That’s why a new paper published by the Macdonald-Laurier Institute – titled Renovating Oakes: Why Section 1 Justifies Reasonable Limits and Not Infringements on Charter Rights – says the Oakes test is in need of a “renovation.”

The authors of that paper, Gerard Kennedy and Geoffrey Sigalet, joined Inside Policy Talks to make that case.

Gerard Kennedy is an associate professor and associate dean at the University of Alberta’s Faculty of Law. He’s also a constitutional lawyer with extensive experience in public law and Charter litigation.

Geoffrey Sigalet is an associate professor of political science at the University of British Columbia and director of the UBC Research Group for Constitutional Law.

On the podcast, they tell Mark Mancini, an MLI senior fellow and assistant professor at Thompson Rivers University Faculty of Law, that when it comes to the Oakes test, courts have drifted away from the Charter’s original logic.

“People are not skeptical enough about what happens in courts, and they are extremely skeptical about what happens in legislatures,” says Sigalet. “And I don't think that they're wrong sometimes about the legislatures. I just think we should be applying our skepticism a bit more evenly.”

Jaksot(116)

Paul Warchuk: Property rights are 'precarious' in Canada

Paul Warchuk: Property rights are 'precarious' in Canada

Across Canada, some of the most heated disputes – from housing restrictions to Indigenous land claims – turn on this question: how secure are Canadians’ property rights?The answer may surprise you. Ca...

4 Joulu 202551min

John Gilmour: Commercial encryption is a challenge for signals intelligence

John Gilmour: Commercial encryption is a challenge for signals intelligence

Canada faces a growing array of national security threats—from foreign interference networks to money laundering operations and organized crime groups exploiting modern digital tools. Yet many of our ...

20 Marras 202521min

Hillel Neuer: The UN matters whether we like it or not

Hillel Neuer: The UN matters whether we like it or not

The UN Human Rights Council contains members like China, Cuba, and Qatar. Yet it remains a highly trusted institution across Western democracies. What should the public understand about the reality of...

13 Marras 202528min

Nathan Pinkoski: What’s behind faltering liberalism?

Nathan Pinkoski: What’s behind faltering liberalism?

Across the Western world, migration, identity, and belonging have moved from policy questions to existential ones. The political and moral assumptions that held our societies together for decades are ...

7 Marras 20251h 8min

Yves Giroux: Soaring spending demands effective parliamentary oversight

Yves Giroux: Soaring spending demands effective parliamentary oversight

It’s been more than 10 months since Canadians got a close look at the federal finances in last fall’s economic statement. At that time, they learned the deficit for the 2023–24 fiscal year had balloon...

30 Loka 202552min

John Adams: Rare diseases reveal hard truths about Canada’s healthcare gaps

John Adams: Rare diseases reveal hard truths about Canada’s healthcare gaps

Rare diseases affect only a small number of Canadians, but a lack of adequate testing and treatment reveals some of the key weaknesses in our health care system.These illnesses – which affect about on...

23 Loka 202548min

Andrew Fox: 'Palestinianism' remains a threat to Middle East peace

Andrew Fox: 'Palestinianism' remains a threat to Middle East peace

There's rapid change happening in Middle East In a ceremonial show of unity, world leaders headed to Egypt for an Oct. 13 peace summit in support of United States President Donald Trump’s plan to end ...

16 Loka 202533min

Stephen Nagy: Canadians should be wary of Chinese influence operations in the West

Stephen Nagy: Canadians should be wary of Chinese influence operations in the West

With the Canada-United States relationship at an all-time low, China has moved quickly to position itself as a beneficiary of the fallout. Canadians should be wary. Beijing is seeking to court Canadia...

9 Loka 202534min

Suosittua kategoriassa Politiikka ja uutiset

aikalisa
ootsa-kuullut-tasta-2
rss-ootsa-kuullut-tasta
tervo-halme
politiikan-puskaradio
viisupodi
rss-vaalirankkurit-podcast
rss-podme-livebox
rss-asiastudio
et-sa-noin-voi-sanoo-esittaa
otetaan-yhdet
the-ulkopolitist
radio-antro
rss-hyvaa-huomenta-bryssel
rss-tasta-on-kyse-ivan-puopolo-verkkouutiset
rss-kalevi-sorsa-saation-podcast
rss-kaikki-uusiksi
rss-merja-mahkan-rahat
rss-kuka-mina-olen
rss-tekkipodi