Talking to the Bank of England about systemic risk and systems engineering

Patrick McKenzie (@patio11) shares his remarks to the Bank of England on critical vulnerabilities in financial infrastructure. Drawing from the July 2024 CrowdStrike outage which brought down teller systems at major US banks, Patrick discusses how regulatory guidance inadvertently created dangerous software monocultures. He also examines the stablecoin market, its impressive growth, and the elephant tethered to the room. He also delivers a message from Silicon Valley to other centers of power on the urgent necessity of waking up regarding AI, which almost the entire world currently far underrates.
–

Full transcript available here: www.complexsystemspodcast.com/talking-to-the-bank-of-england/

–

Sponsor: Framer is a design and publishing platform that collapses the toolchain between wireframes and production-ready websites. Design, iterate, and publish in one workspace. Start free at framer.com/design with code COMPLEXSYSTEMS for a free month of Framer Pro.
–

Links:

• The Bank of England: https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/
• Bits about Money, Why the CrowdStrike bug hit banks hard: https://www.bitsaboutmoney.com/archive/crowdstrike-bug-hit-banks-hard/
• Scaling Laws for Neural Language Models" by Kaplan et al: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2001.08361
• Stripe Annual Letter 2024: https://stripe.com/annual-updates/2024

–

Timestamps:

(00:00) Intro
(01:48) The importance of implementation-level understanding
(03:00) Single points of failure
(04:25) Can a 22-year-old engineer close all the banks?
(05:18) The CrowdStrike incident: A case study
(08:34) The culture of "shut up and shuffle"
(09:54) Blameless postmortems
(12:25) What actually happened during CrowdStrike
(18:01) Five whys: Root cause analysis
(19:03) How software monocultures are created
(22:54) Understanding endpoint monitoring software
(25:25) Distributed systems and the nature of CrowdStrike
(31:22) The economics of software monocultures
(33:29) Why wasn't there defense in depth?
(37:05) Why was recovery so difficult?
(40:32) The domino effect across financial institutions
(43:36) What went right: Electronic systems remained up
(45:10) This was a near miss
(49:29) Potential policy responses
(54:03) Switching gears: Stablecoins
(01:01:37) The elephant in the room: Tether
(01:15:32) Who loses if Tether implodes?
(01:16:59) AI and the future of trading
(01:26:47) AI risks in the trading space
(01:30:41) Closing