Iran Won Because America Is Stuck in the ‘Smart Bomb Trap’

Recorded in May. Join angryplanetpod.com to hear episodes early and commercial free.

America’s war against Iran has gone on for more than two months and the United States has achieved none of its political objectives. American power has diminished, its munitions stockpile is low, and Iran now controls the Strait of Hormuz.

Tehran has all the cards.

To hear Robert Pape tell it, this was all predictable. Pape is a political scientist who teaches at the University of Chicago and specializes in the use of violence to achieve political goals. He’s the author of Bombing to Win and a scholar of air power failures. On this episode of Angry Planet, Pape walks us through the uses of air power, why it never achieves victory on its own, and why the Pentagon keeps promising it will.

How you become an air power expert
Losing Vietnam after such perfect precision
Man as meme
“You don’t learn this by real estate deals.”
There has not been a single case in history where air power alone has succeeded.
“Our power is declining as a result of this.”
The persistent myth of winning through air power
Dumb bombs to precision weapons
“It’s a dismal record of failure.”
NATO in Kosovo
What are America’s definable political goals?
Iran’s political goals
Iran says seized tanker in Gulf of Oman, as US ‘disables’ two ships
Punishment, denial, and decapitation
The fragmenting GCC
Pape as Casandra
Breaking Trump in the Strait of Hormuz
“This will end up being America’s worst defeat since Vietnam.”
A grim prediction

The Escalation Trap

The Gulf States Just Voted on American Power

From Kosovo to Iran: The Smart Bomb Trap and the Risk of Catastrophic Escalation

Buy Bombing to Win: Air Power and Coercion in War

Support this show http://supporter.acast.com/warcollege.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Tämä jakso on lisätty Podme-palveluun avoimen RSS-syötteen kautta eikä se ole Podmen omaa tuotantoa. Siksi jakso saattaa sisältää mainontaa.

Jaksot(502)

If You Must Fight a Trade War, Fight to Win

The world I grew up in no longer exists. The decades after World War II were boom times for free trade lovers. During the Pax Americana it seemed that most diplomatic problems could be solved by expor...

3 Heinä 54min

Navigating Reality and War During the Age of AI Propaganda

On the morning of April 21, Trump posted an image of eight women on Truth Social, claimed they were Iranian dissidents set to be executed, and demanded that Tehran release them. Detractors, and severa...

5 Kesä 59min

Christianity Shaped North Korea’s Cult of Personality

Kim Song Ju, the man who would become Kim Il Sung, was born to devout Presbyterian parents. Billy Graham’s wife was born to christian missionaries in China and went to high school in Pyongyang. Americ...

8 Touko 1h

Making the Case America Was Winning in Iran

Recorded March 24, 2026. Subscribe at angryplanetpod.com to hear episodes first and commercial free.Last week an article published in Al Jazeera by an academic at the University of Doha in Qatar propo...

10 Huhti 1h 3min

Neutralizing Iran’s Nuclear Material During a War Is ‘Nearly Mission Impossible’

America went to war in Iran, we’re told, because the idea of the country developing nuclear weapons was intolerable. Nukes are complicated and technical weapons that require scientists and experts to ...

27 Maalis 54min

The ‘AI as Nuclear Weapons’ Obsession

AI enthusiasts love to say that the technology is as revolutionary and important as nuclear weapons. Even the Trump administration has adopted the metaphor. The President and the Department of Energy ...

13 Maalis 1h 2min

A Killer True Crime Fandom & Islamic State’s Digital Caliphate

Things have gotten very surreal in the dark corners of the internet. AI-generated prophets are preaching jihad in Facebook groups, Minecraft servers host digital caliphates, and school shooting fandom...

4 Maalis 1h 22min