Listen Now: Suspect "Five Shots in the Dark"

Thank you Katie for requesting this case!On the evening of November 17th, 1973,  five teenage friends decided to head to the Gitchie Manitou State Preserve located in the far northwestern corner of Io...

26 Maalis 202543min

Today, we are going back in time; let’s rewind the clock to 1969, the year the world got slightly brighter—because Jen and I came into being. But hold on tight because we’re about to dive into the sce...

19 Maalis 202547min

Episode requested by Anthony W. Thank you, Anthony!Welcome to OTCP's 300th regular episode! ******Content Warning: Sexual assault and death of children*********In this episode, we dive into Canada's m...

12 Maalis 20251h 35min

It is November 6th, 1990. The air was crisp, the Belt Parkway humming with the usual New York traffic. Among the cars was Eddie Lino—an old-school Gambino enforcer, a man whose name carried weight in ...

5 Maalis 202557min

Thank you to Charity, who requested the episode!In the quiet town of Georgetown, Indiana, former state trooper David Camm’s life was torn apart when he came home and found his wife, Kim, and their two...

26 Helmi 202550min

The night of April 19, 1997, was like any other Saturday at Tony’s Pizza in Hardyston, New Jersey. The dinner rush had come and gone, and as the clock neared 10:45 p.m., Jeremy Giordano,  22, and Gior...

19 Helmi 202534min

15-year-old Rachel Barber. a bright and promising teenager from Melbourne, Australia, disappeared after leaving class in 1999.Rachel's boyfriend told the Barbers his cryptic conversation he had with R...

12 Helmi 202553min

Nestled in the small, unassuming town of Stella, Missouri, in the heart of the Ozarks, nine-year-old Rowan Ford lived a life like any kid would. She shared a modest home in Newton County with her moth...

5 Helmi 202540min