Bill Doolin and the Wild Bunch: How Bounties Killed the Outlaw West

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

In the winter of 1895, an aging man with a ruined foot soaked in a bathhouse in Eureka Springs, Arkansas. He was Bill Doolin, founder of the Wild Bunch, and he was about to be arrested without firing a shot. This episode traces how he got there. Born in 1858 to a sharecropping family in Johnson County, Arkansas, Doolin left for Indian Territory in 1881 and found work on Oscar Halsell's ranch alongside George Newcomb, Charlie Pierce, and Emmett Dalton. A street shootout over confiscated beer in Coffeyville, Kansas on July 4th, 1891 made him a wanted man with nowhere to go but crime.

Doolin is widely suspected of being the sixth man who held the horses and slipped away when the Dalton Gang was shot to pieces trying to rob two Coffeyville banks at once in October 1892. He studied that failure and built a smarter gang, with safe houses, paid sympathizers, and teenage lookouts. Then a bullet in the foot cost him his mobility, a dead deputy marshal brought federal pursuit, and reward money turned friends into informers. The episode treats his fall as the story of how the frontier itself closed.

• Coffeyville townspeople did not wait for the sheriff. They armed themselves at the hardware stores and caught the Daltons in a crossfire that killed four outlaws.
• Two teenage girls remembered as Cattle Annie and Little Britches listened to lawmen's gossip in town and carried warnings back to the gang.
• In September 1893, 14 U.S. Marshals surrounded Ingalls, Oklahoma. Doolin killed Deputy Marshal Richard Speed and escaped, which drew in the Three Guardsmen: Bill Tilghman, Chris Madsen, and Heck Thomas.
• In May 1895 George Newcomb and Charlie Pierce were killed for the reward by the older brothers of Newcomb's teenage girlfriend, Rose Dunn.
• Doolin broke out of jail in the summer of 1896 only to see his wife. Heck Thomas tracked him down that August and killed him with a shotgun at age 38.