Lillian & Drew - She Might’ve Ruined the Date… with Shrimp and ChatGPT?
Lillian thought the chemistry was real — until her dinner order and her digital sidekick may have blown it. In this hilarious and cringe-filled First Date Follow-Up, we find out why Drew vanished afte...
13 Elo 202511min
Ryan & Shanna - The Ice Cream Incident
When Ryan planned a perfect first date—complete with pizza, ice cream, and a live band—he never imagined a bad joke would nearly cost him a second one. In this hilarious and awkward episode of First D...
12 Elo 202511min
Molly & Raef - Arcade Date Gone Wrong? Why Raef Vanished After the Retro Night?
Molly thought her throwback arcade date with Raef was a total win — flirty competition, a romantic slow dance by the DDR machine, and even a shared pretzel. But after a literal crash moment, he disapp...
11 Elo 202511min
Cal & Teresa - Glamping, Gaslighting, and the Great Bug Escape
Cal thought he planned the perfect first date — wine, s'mores, a cozy glamping tent, and a binge session of The Bear. But now Teresa won’t return his texts, and he wants answers. Was it the swarm of b...
8 Elo 202510min
Tripp & Bri - Ghosted After a 5-Star Date — But Not for the Reason You’d Think
Tripp went all out for his first date with Bri — luxury ride, fine dining, seafood towers, and a bottle of wine to top it off. So why did she vanish right after dessert? He thinks it’s something minor...
7 Elo 202511min
Cassidy & Luke - Soup, Salt, and Second Chances: The First Date That Got a Little... Seasoned
What do artisanal salt grinders, passionate monologues, and an unexpected hand kiss have in common? They’re all part of one unforgettable first date that left Cassidy ghosting — and Luke scratching hi...
6 Elo 202511min
Caleb & Naomi - Ghosted After the Hot Sauce Challenge?
Caleb thought his pottery date with Naomi was going great — until the infamous hot sauce challenge went sideways, and now he’s getting ghosted. What really happened after the tacos and the playful pot...
5 Elo 202512min
Celly Cell Strikes Again: Corn, Chemistry & a Public Chase?
Repeat guest Celly Cell is back on the scene with another unforgettable first date follow-up—and things escalated fast. From flirty food festival vibes to unexpected PDA and a bold move near the pickl...
4 Elo 202511min
