The Vanishing of Mary Day: A Missing Girl’s Impossible Return
A 13-year-old girl disappears. No missing persons report. No search. No questions.For over two decades, Mary Day was nothing more than a distant, painful memory—until one day, a woman appeared, claiming to be her.Was she really the missing girl? Or was this an elaborate deception?With suspicious parents, a buried secret, and a DNA test that only made things more confusing, this case left investigators questioning everything.A disappearance. A discovery. A mystery that may never be solved.Join us as we unravel the bizarre and chilling case of Mary Day—the girl who vanished and the woman who came back.🔗 Visit our website for more episodes: https://rss.com/podcasts/crimepod-castle/ 🎧 Don’t forget to subscribe for more unbelievable true crime stories.Hashtags:#TrueCrime #CrimePodcast #MaryDay #UnsolvedMystery #CrimePodCastle #TwistedCrime #MissingPerson #DNAInvestigation #ColdCase #UnbelievableButTrue
31 Tammi 12min
A Father's Deadly Ultimatum: The Murder of Michelle Nyreider
What would you do if the person you trusted most asked you to commit the unthinkable?On August 28, 2017, Michelle Nyreider was found dead at the bottom of her staircase, a rope tied around her neck. At first glance, it looked like a tragic suicide. But the truth was far more sinister.A bitter custody battle. A father willing to do anything to escape child support. And a daughter caught in the ultimate act of betrayal.Was Karrie Nyreider an accomplice, or was she just another victim of her father’s twisted manipulation?Join us as we unravel the shocking case of Michelle Nyreider’s murder, a story of love, control, and the devastating power of psychological abuse.🔗 Visit our website for more episodes: https://rss.com/podcasts/crimepod-castle/ 🎧 Don’t forget to subscribe for more gripping true crime stories.Hashtags:#TrueCrime #CrimePodcast #MichelleNyreider #CrimePodCastle #JusticeForMichelle #FamilyBetrayal #TwistedCrime #CrimeOfManipulation #DomesticAbuse #CustodyBattle
31 Tammi 14min
A Love That Turned Deadly: The Murder of Haley Anderson
Haley Anderson was a bright, compassionate nursing student with her whole life ahead of her. But in March 2018, she was found strangled in the bed of her ex-lover, Orlando Tercero. The man responsible? He had fled the country—escaping to Nicaragua, where justice seemed out of reach.A crime of passion. A desperate escape. And an international fight for justice that changed everything.Join us as we uncover the tragic case of Haley Anderson, a young woman whose life was stolen by an obsessive love that turned into a deadly obsession.🔗 Visit our website for more episodes: https://rss.com/podcasts/crimepod-castle/ 🎧 Don’t forget to subscribe for more gripping true crime stories.Hashtags:#TrueCrime #CrimePodcast #HaleyAnderson #CrimePodCastle #JusticeForHaley #DomesticViolence #ToxicLove #CrimeOfPassion #TwistedCrime #Femicide
30 Tammi 18min
The Year They Disappeared: A Family’s Fight Against a Murder Plot
On August 31, 1979, a gunman pulled up beside Officer John Busby’s car and fired a shotgun blast through his window. Miraculously, he survived—but his family’s nightmare was just beginning.Who wanted him dead? Why did an entire town refuse to investigate? And how did the Busby family go from living a peaceful life in Falmouth, Massachusetts, to disappearing overnight, forced into hiding to escape a ruthless enemy?Join us as we unravel the chilling true story of The Year They Disappeared, a tale of power, corruption, and a father’s desperate fight to protect his family from the man who controlled an entire town.🔗 Visit our website for more episodes: https://rss.com/podcasts/crimepod-castle/ 🎧 Don’t forget to subscribe for more gripping true crime stories.Hashtags:#TrueCrime #CrimePodcast #UnsolvedMystery #TheYearTheyDisappeared #CrimePodCastle #Corruption #JusticeServed #SurvivorStory #MurderPlot #TwistedCrime
30 Tammi 13min
The Stranger You Thought You Knew: The Attack on Marty Hill
On September 8, 2010, what should have been a routine day turned into a nightmarish fight for survival. Marty Hill, a hardworking professional and loving mother, was brutally attacked in her own home—beaten, strangled, and left for dead in her basement.The crime scene pointed to an act of personal rage, but the real horror? The attacker wasn’t a stranger. It was someone Marty had trusted, someone she had let inside without hesitation.In this episode, we unravel the shocking story of The Attack on Marty Hill, a case that reminds us that sometimes, the greatest threats aren’t lurking in the shadows—they're standing right beside us.🔗 Visit our website for more episodes: https://rss.com/podcasts/crimepod-castle/ 🎧 Don’t forget to subscribe for more gripping true crime stories.Hashtags:#TrueCrime #MartyHill #CrimePodcast #SurvivorStory #CrimePodCastle #JusticeServed #CrimeInvestigation #TwistedCrime #DangerAmongUs
29 Tammi 11min
The Coleman Family Murders: Writing on the Wall
In the serene suburb of Columbia, Illinois, tragedy struck on May 5, 2009, when Sherry Coleman and her two sons, Garrett and Gavin, were found brutally murdered in their home. Chilling messages spray-painted on the walls pointed to a vengeful killer, but the truth was far more shocking than anyone could imagine.As investigators peeled back the layers, they uncovered a web of deceit, an illicit affair, and a cold-blooded plan to escape a life of lies. Join us as we explore The Coleman Family Murders, a tale of betrayal, heartbreak, and ultimate justice.🔗 Visit our website for more episodes: https://rss.com/podcasts/crimepod-castle/ 🎧 Don’t forget to subscribe for more gripping true crime stories.Hashtags:#TrueCrime #ColemanFamilyMurders #CrimePodcast #DomesticViolenceAwareness #TrueCrimeCommunity #CrimePodCastle #CrimeStories #JusticeForSherry #DarkSecrets
29 Tammi 10min
Paradise Lost: The Tragic Mystery of Yvonne Baldelli
What happens when paradise hides a nightmare? In 2011, Yvonne Baldelli and her boyfriend, Brian Brimager, moved to the idyllic Isla Carenero in Panama, seeking a fresh start. But only Brian returned home, spinning a web of lies about Yvonne’s disappearance.As the truth unraveled, a tale of betrayal, violence, and relentless determination emerged. With the backdrop of tropical beauty, this episode explores the chilling mystery of Devil’s Island: The Yvonne Baldelli Case—a story of love turned lethal and a family’s unwavering fight for justice.🔗 Visit our website for more episodes: https://rss.com/podcasts/crimepod-castle/ 🎧 Subscribe and follow for more compelling true crime stories.Hashtags:#TrueCrime #YvonneBaldelli #CrimePodcast #JusticeForYvonne #DomesticViolence #PanamaCrime #TrueCrimeCommunity #CrimePodCastle #UnsolvedMysteries #CrimeStories
28 Tammi 13min
A Storm of Secrets: The Crystal McDowell Case"
In the midst of Hurricane Harvey's devastation in 2017, a mother of two vanished without a trace. Crystal McDowell’s disappearance left her family and community desperate for answers, as rising floodwaters complicated the search. A love triangle, hidden secrets, and one man’s obsession unravelled into a tragic tale of betrayal and loss.This episode explores Crystal’s life, the chilling details of her final moments, and the relentless pursuit of justice against overwhelming odds. Join us as we uncover the story of Storm of Suspicion: The Crystal McDowell Case—a haunting reminder of the darkness that can lurk even in times of unity and survival.🔗 Visit our website for more episodes: https://rss.com/podcasts/crimepod-castle/ 🎧 Subscribe and follow for more gripping true crime stories.Hashtags:#TrueCrime #CrystalMcDowell #StormOfSuspicion #DomesticViolence #TrueCrimePodcast #JusticeForCrystal #CrimeStories #UnsolvedMysteries #CrimePodCastle #HurricaneHarvey
28 Tammi 23min
