Racism, the criminal justice system, and data science
Linear Digressions7 Kesä 2020

Racism, the criminal justice system, and data science

As protests sweep across the United States in the wake of the killing of George Floyd by a Minneapolis police officer, we take a moment to dig into one of the ways that data science perpetuates and amplifies racism in the American criminal justice system. COMPAS is an algorithm that claims to give a prediction about the likelihood of an offender to re-offend if released, based on the attributes of the individual, and guess what: it shows disparities in the predictions for black and white offenders that would nudge judges toward giving harsher sentences to black individuals. We dig into this algorithm a little more deeply, unpacking how different metrics give different pictures into the “fairness” of the predictions and what is causing its racially disparate output (to wit: race is explicitly not an input to the algorithm, and yet the algorithm gives outputs that correlate with race—what gives?) Unfortunately it’s not an open-and-shut case of a tuning parameter being off, or the wrong metric being used: instead the biases in the justice system itself are being captured in the algorithm outputs, in such a way that a self-fulfilling prophecy of harsher treatment for black defendants is all but guaranteed. Like many other things this week, this episode left us thinking about bigger, systemic issues, and why it’s proven so hard for years to fix what’s broken.

Tämä jakso on lisätty Podme-palveluun avoimen RSS-syötteen kautta eikä se ole Podmen omaa tuotantoa. Siksi jakso saattaa sisältää mainontaa.

Jaksot(316)

Invisible LLM Failures and AI Fluency with Chris Potts (Stanford)

Invisible LLM Failures and AI Fluency with Chris Potts (Stanford)

What happens when a Stanford linguistics professor turns his attention to AI chatbots — and the surprisingly invisible ways humans misunderstand them? Chris Potts joins the show to unpack the hidden f...

20 Heinä 41min

Still summer break: back next week

Still summer break: back next week

Still summer break: back next week by Katie Malone

13 Heinä 25s

Summer break: back soon

Summer break: back soon

Summer break: back soon by Katie Malone

6 Heinä 36s

Interviewing the Linear Digressions Agents (The Agents Season, Episode 11)

Interviewing the Linear Digressions Agents (The Agents Season, Episode 11)

After a five-year hiatus, the podcast that burned out partly over the tedium of writing episode descriptions is back — and using AI agents to handle exactly that task. The season-11 finale turns the l...

28 Kesä 37min

Agent Economics (The Agents Season, Episode 10)

Agent Economics (The Agents Season, Episode 10)

What if building more highways made your commute *slower*? That's the paradox at the heart of AI agent economics: even as per-token inference costs have plummeted dramatically over the past two years,...

22 Kesä 24min

Agent Trust, Oversight and Control (The Agents Season, Episode 9)

Agent Trust, Oversight and Control (The Agents Season, Episode 9)

Capabilities get all the attention when it comes to AI agents — but what happens when a highly capable agent makes a bad decision in the real world? Trust, oversight, and control are the unglamorous b...

15 Kesä 25min

Many Agents, Many Problems (The Agents Season, Episode 8)

Many Agents, Many Problems (The Agents Season, Episode 8)

Whether you work best solo or thrive in a team, you know collaboration is complicated — and it turns out AI agents face the same tensions. This episode dives into multi-agent systems, exploring how ne...

8 Kesä 28min

How Do You Evaluate An AI Agent? (The Agents Season, Episode 7)

How Do You Evaluate An AI Agent? (The Agents Season, Episode 7)

Knowing when an AI agent has failed sounds straightforward — until it isn't. Agents have a frustrating habit of finishing confidently while quietly doing the wrong thing, or looping endlessly without ...

1 Kesä 31min