How Do I Choose a Plastic Surgeon?

Choose a plastic surgeon by considering qualifications, relevant work and the quality of your consultation together. A recommendation, star rating or photo gallery can help you begin your research, but none tells the whole story.

In this June 27, 2020 episode of Plastic Surgery: Before and After, board-certified New York City plastic surgeon Darren M. Smith, MD outlines five areas to examine: word of mouth, reviews, before-and-after photographs, training and credentials, and communication during a consultation.

Key takeaways

🔎 Use referrals as a starting point.

A friend or colleague's experience may identify a surgeon worth meeting.

🔎 Read reviews for context.

Dr. Smith recommends looking beyond a simple star count and discussing concerns directly during the consultation.

🔎 Explore relevant photographs.

A gallery can help you discuss the surgeon's aesthetic approach and experience with the procedure that interests you.

🔎 Check credentials.

The episode emphasizes certification by the American Board of Plastic Surgery, along with the surgeon's training.

💬 Pay attention to communication.

Dr. Smith describes surgery as a collaboration in which questions, expectations and a comfortable working relationship matter.

💬 Questions answered

Should a surgeon's limited online presence rule them out?

Not automatically. The episode explains that some experienced surgeons have few online reviews. Dr. Smith recommends considering their other qualifications and meeting them rather than judging only by digital visibility.

Can I ask to see more before-and-after photographs?

Yes. Dr. Smith notes that some patients permit their photographs to be shown privately in the office but not published online. Ask about examples relevant to the procedure you are considering; another person's result is not a guarantee of your own.

Where can I verify plastic surgery board certification?

The American Board of Plastic Surgery's official search provides certification information. Certification is one important credential to evaluate alongside the rest of the consultation and your specific needs.

🎧 Episode chapters

00:31 — Five considerations when choosing a surgeon

02:07 — Reading online reviews in context

04:17 — Using before-and-after photographs

05:33 — Communication at the consultation

06:01 — Training and board certification

🔗 Related information

Explore Dr. Smith's training and background, practice information, or request a consultation with Dr. Smith in New York City.

About the host — current biography

Darren M. Smith, MD, FACS specializes in mommy makeover surgery, breast surgery, and body contouring in Manhattan. He was named to Newsweek’s America’s Best Plastic Surgeons 2026 and has co-authored authoritative peer-reviewed publications on combined breast surgery and abdominoplasty and the surgical care of postpartum patients.

Originally released June 27, 2020. Show notes updated September 30, 2026. This is general education. Current recommendations, suitability, risks and expected results require an individual assessment.

Full transcript and related resources