The Strange Disappearance of Polly Feltner
Stories of Appalachia15 Maalis 2025

The Strange Disappearance of Polly Feltner

In this episode, we tell the strange tale of Polly Feltner, a young woman from Hyden, Kentucky, who vanished in 1897 under mysterious circumstances.

What began as a search for a missing person quickly escalated into charges of murder, a frenzy of suspicion and mob justice, targeting an innocent man. As tensions rose and a near-lynching unfolded, the story took a dramatic twist that no one could have anticipated.

Join us as we tell Polly's unique Appalachian story.

Be sure to subscribe on your favorite podcast app to catch all our stories.

You can also support our storytelling journey and access exclusive content by becoming a patron here: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/stories-of-appalachia--5553692/support

Thanks for listening!

Jaksot(585)

The Blue People of Kentucky

The Blue People of Kentucky

In 1820 French orphan Martin Fugate and his wife Elizabeth arrived as new settlers in eastern Kentucky. Unknown to them, they carried genetic traits that would pass on to their descendants, causing m...

8 Heinä 202313min

The Mysterious Christmas Eve Fire: The Missing Sodder Children and their Haunting Legacy

The Mysterious Christmas Eve Fire: The Missing Sodder Children and their Haunting Legacy

On Christmas Eve, 1945, a mysterious fire broke out at the Fayetteville, West Virginia home of George and Jennie Sodder. Try as they might, George and his oldest son were unable to put out the fire, n...

1 Heinä 202316min

The Dark Mystery of the Sensabaugh Tunnel

The Dark Mystery of the Sensabaugh Tunnel

Theft. Infanticide. Insanity. Murder. Ghosts.The stories that surround a notorious tunnel in Tennessee contain all those elements and more.Today we tell some of those stories and tell you a little...

24 Kesä 202311min

Haunted Waters: The Tragic Tale of the Siren's Song in the French Broad River

Haunted Waters: The Tragic Tale of the Siren's Song in the French Broad River

A tale was told by the Cherokee of a siren that inhabited the deep whirlpools of the French Broad River in western North Carolina. These sirens were said to be demons that would lure men to their dea...

17 Kesä 202310min

Sam's Magnificent Beard

Sam's Magnificent Beard

A mountain farmer and schoolteacher from the North Carolina town of Magnetic City (now Buladean) got so tired of shaving that he tossed his straight razor in the garbage and just let that facial hair ...

10 Kesä 202319min

The Appalachian Insurrection of 1917

The Appalachian Insurrection of 1917

As the United States entered World War I, it was found to be necessary to start drafting men to serve in the military. That decision was met with widespread resistance across the country, with protest...

3 Kesä 202316min

The Kentucky Cannibal: Boone Helm

The Kentucky Cannibal: Boone Helm

Right before and during the Civil War an outlaw roamed the West who was unlike any of the other outlaws you might have heard of. This man, born and raised in eastern Kentucky, gained a reputation for...

27 Touko 202315min

An Appalachian Frontier Legend: Simon Kenton, Part Two

An Appalachian Frontier Legend: Simon Kenton, Part Two

Today we wrap up our story about legendary Appalachian explorer, longhunter and guide Simon Kenton, who went from explorer and longhunter to owning hundreds of thousands of acres of frontier land, bus...

20 Touko 202318min

Suosittua kategoriassa Yhteiskunta

olipa-kerran-otsikko
sita
siita-on-vaikea-puhua
gogin-ja-janin-maailmanhistoria
i-dont-like-mondays
kaksi-aitia
uutiscast
poks
antin-palautepalvelu
rss-nikotellen
kolme-kaannekohtaa
mamma-mia
yopuolen-tarinoita-2
rss-murhan-anatomia
aikalisa
meidan-pitais-puhua
rss-haudattu
rss-palmujen-varjoissa
isani-on-terapeuttiville
mystista