Shai Dothan: International Judicial Review, Chapter 3.
Shai Dothan23 Elo 2021

Shai Dothan: International Judicial Review, Chapter 3.

Chapter 3 targets another challenge to international courts' intervention: the argument that international courts do not make better decisions than national bodies. The chapter identifies a set of circumstances in which international courts, solely because of their institutional position and regardless of the proficiency of their judges, are actually able to make better decisions than national courts. The core of the argument is the Condorcet Jury Theorem, which suggests that a majority decision within a group is likely to be superior to the decision of each individual decision-maker, provided that each decision-maker decides independently. If national judges try to learn from comparative law, they violate the independence condition because they learn from courts who followed other courts instead of deciding independently. If instead, national courts decide independently and an international court follows the majority position—as the ECHR does when it uses the Emerging Consensus doctrine—the decisional benefit of the Jury Theorem is fully realized. The chapter goes through several judgments and judicial doctrines to demonstrate how doctrine can be used to maximize the decisional advantage of international courts and counter some harmful incentives of the countries involved. This separate paper describes the key arguments in the chapter: https://privpapers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2597949

Tämä jakso on lisätty Podme-palveluun avoimen RSS-syötteen kautta eikä se ole Podmen omaa tuotantoa. Siksi jakso saattaa sisältää mainontaa.

Jaksot(12)

A Comparison of the Early Writings of Nietzsche and Kierkegaard - Part 4 (last part)

A Comparison of the Early Writings of Nietzsche and Kierkegaard - Part 4 (last part)

This is the fourth and last in a series of four short lectures that describe the similarities and differences between the early work of the Danish philosopher Søren Kierkegaard and the German philosop...

23 Maalis 202227min

A Comparison of the Early Writings of Nietzsche and Kierkegaard - Part 3

A Comparison of the Early Writings of Nietzsche and Kierkegaard - Part 3

This is the third in a series of four short lectures that describe the similarities and differences between the early work of the Danish philosopher Søren Kierkegaard and the German philosopher Friedr...

23 Maalis 202226min

A Comparison of the Early Writings of Nietzsche and Kierkegaard - Part 2

A Comparison of the Early Writings of Nietzsche and Kierkegaard - Part 2

This is the second in a series of four short lectures that describe the similarities and differences between the early work of the Danish philosopher Søren Kierkegaard and the German philosopher Fried...

23 Maalis 202223min

A Comparison of the Early Writings of Nietzsche and Kierkegaard - Part 1

A Comparison of the Early Writings of Nietzsche and Kierkegaard - Part 1

This is the first in a series of four short lectures that describe the similarities and differences between the early work of the Danish philosopher Søren Kierkegaard and the German philosopher Friedr...

23 Maalis 202226min

Shai Dothan: International Judicial Review, The Conclusion.

Shai Dothan: International Judicial Review, The Conclusion.

The Conclusion describes briefly the contents of Chapter 7 of the book that is focused on contrasting the theories in the book with established theories of domestic judicial review and on presenting d...

24 Elo 20216min

Shai Dothan: International Judicial Review, Chapter 6.

Shai Dothan: International Judicial Review, Chapter 6.

Chapter 6 faces the final challenge to international courts' intervention, the fear that their intervention would lead to bad outcomes because it would change the incentives of relevant parties. It is...

24 Elo 20215min

Shai Dothan: International Judicial Review, Chapter 5.

Shai Dothan: International Judicial Review, Chapter 5.

Chapter 5 is focused on the risk of capture of international courts by NGOs. The chapter reviews the advantages and disadvantages of NGO involvement in international courts' proceedings either as dire...

24 Elo 20219min

Shai Dothan: International Judicial Review, Chapter 4.

Shai Dothan: International Judicial Review, Chapter 4.

Chapter 4 replies to the argument that international courts who decide important policy decisions take them off the public agenda and therefore stifle public debate. The chapter explains that an inter...

23 Elo 202110min

Suosittua kategoriassa Tiede

rss-poliisin-mieli
rss-mita-tulisi-tietaa
tiedekulma-podcast
docemilia
rss-tiedetta-vai-tarinaa
rss-bios-podcast
rss-duodecim-lehti
rss-hereilla
rss-lapsuuden-rakentajat-podcast
utelias-mieli
radio-antro
hippokrateen-vastaanotolla
filocast-filosofian-perusteet