Three terrifying Amish murders
This week, Amy and Chris bring you three murders committed in the typically peaceful Amish community. The first is about Ed Gingerich, a mentally ill man who brutally murdered and disemboweled his wif...
12 Touko 202137min
Tik Toker Kills Sister PLUS! Law & Order-Inspired Cold Case
"I stabbed my sister!" These were the words repeated over and over by Claire Miller, the 14-year-old who allegedly stabbed her sister Helen to death and posted the video on Tik Tok. In the first case,...
28 Huhti 202126min
Two cold cases solved by DNA: Mandy Stavik & Lisa Ziegert
This week, Amy and Chris are highlighting 2 remarkable cases that were solved using modern DNA techniques. The first story is the case of Mandy Stavik, who was found dead on Nov. 27, 1989. With no sig...
21 Huhti 202129min
What Happened To The McStay Family?
This week, Amy and Chris delve into 2 horrific family murders. In the first half, Chris recounts the slaying of the McStay Family in the affluent Fallbrook, California. The McStay Family consisted of ...
14 Huhti 202134min
Everything we know about the death of Dr. Amie Harwick
In two tragic stories of a former loved one turning into murderers, Amy and Chris bring you the cases of Dr. Amie Harwick and Britney Ujlaky. First up, Amy recaps how Amie Harwick was murdered by an o...
7 Huhti 202129min
A doctor, a dentist, and a jilted girlfriend. Kendra Hatcher Murder-for-Hire Plot
In the first story, Chris discusses the story of an angry ex-girlfriend that turned deadly, the murder of Kendra Hatcher. Dr. Ricardo “Ricky” Paniagua broke things off with Brenda Delgado via email, w...
31 Maalis 202124min
The Amityville Horror True Story - 2021 Update!
In the first story, Amy details the infamous Amityville murders from 1974, as well as a recent update to the story. Ronald DeFeo was arrested for the murder of six family members in their home in Amit...
24 Maalis 202132min
Heather Elvis’ affair with married man leads to deadly love triangle
In the first story, Chris discusses the disappearance of Heather Elvis. Heather unknowingly began an affair with Sidney Moorer, a co-worker at the restaurant where she worked. Eventually, Sidney's wif...
17 Maalis 202126min
