My Response to Sam Harris on the Apple Encryption Debate

My Response to Sam Harris on the Apple Encryption Debate



[ Subscribe to the Podcast: iTunes | Android | RSS ]

[ UPDATE: Much credit to Sam for engaging in the conversation. I’m not sure how people claim he’s closed on this topic when he is clearly open to exploring it. ]

I don't agree with all of it. But this is a very good response to my remarks about encryption. https://t.co/rMl8zgtuWN@danielmiessler— Sam Harris (@SamHarrisOrg) February 28, 2016





I’ve been planning on doing a podcast episode on the Apple encryption debate for some time, but I was unsure of the format I should use.

This problem was just solved for me when I listened to Sam Harris—who is someone I respect greatly—miss the mark significantly in a recent podcast.

The thing that compelled me to respond was the fact that I don’t often disagree with Sam. His logic is usually impeccable, and we often end up with nearly identical opinions.

So it was somewhat surreal to hear him be wrong about something. Or at least disagree with me (which, of course, may not be the same thing).

Anyway, being in information security myself I felt like a response was important.

This essay takes the form of a retort to his comments, followed by my own points and then a summary.

Sam’s points

[ The points are summarized, by the way, not necessarily exact quotes. ]


* Apple built the lock, but didn’t build the key, and now they’re telling us that building the key would put us all at risk. Self-serving abdication of responsibility.
* Community in tech swayed by Snowden. Even when the government gets a court order, they think they shouldn’t give access
* Gives cases where text messages could have helped solve a murder, but the texts are unread because the iPhone is unbreakable. Imagine being a family member!
* Could someone build an impregnable room inside their own house?
* What if you could take a drug that could make your DNA unanalyzable? So you could never be linked to any crime. The only people who would benefit would be criminals!
* Apple could maintain the backdoor and it’d be fine, just like banks have your banking information. They’re trading on paranoia.


My responses

[ NOTE: This will come in the form of a podcast, which I may still record. I wrote it largely in the voice of a spoken conversation. ]

First, let’s start with where we agree.

You speak of a “Cult of Privacy”, where people are blindly saying that Snowden did nothing wrong whatsoever, that he didn’t set a dangerous precedent, that any violation of privacy in any case is always bad, etc., etc.

I absolutely agree with you that this is not an intelligent way to understand and discuss current events.

But there’s another cult on the other side, and it’s one that you’re coming dangerous close to membership in. And that’s “The Cult of Safety”. This one works like this: If there is any situation in which some amount of data could be used to help learn where a kidnapped girl is, or where a terrorist’s bomb will detonate, then it’s within the rights of a government to legally seize ...

Become a Member: https://danielmiessler.com/upgrade

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Jaksot(532)

NO. 394 — Vegas Recap, CISA MS Alert, China/US AI Fight, Deceased Kid AI, Following vs. Leading…

NO. 394 — Vegas Recap, CISA MS Alert, China/US AI Fight, Deceased Kid AI, Following vs. Leading…

In this episode: 🎰 Back from Vegas: Event Recap🔬 Covid Testing: Importance of Correct Method🔥 Burnout and Addiction: Shared Root Cause🪳 Vulnerabilities🎩 Black Hat Highlights: Tool Releases👥 Lapsus$ Tactics: Simple Techniques, Big Breaches🤖 AI Cyber Challenge: DARPA's Call to Arms🔒 Cybersecurity Standings: US vs China🌐 Render's Cloudflare Issue: Network Errors🔍 PromQL Guardrails: Code Scanning with Semgrep🔭 Tool & Article Discovery➡️ The Recommendation of the Week🗣️ The Aphorism of the WeekBecome a Member: https://danielmiessler.com/upgradeSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

16 Elo 202319min

No. 393 - Hacker Week, Deleting Google Info, And Creating High-Entropy Content

No. 393 - Hacker Week, Deleting Google Info, And Creating High-Entropy Content

In this episode: 🎉 HackerCon Week: BSides, Blackhat, DEFCON🔒 Google's Privacy Update: Control Your Data🤖 AI Vulnerability: Adversarial Attacks on Chatbots🛡️ NIST CSF Changes: Are You Ready?📊 Breach Disclosure Rules: SEC's New Mandate🔧 Tech Giants' Security Fixes: Apple, Google, Microsoft📚 Penetration Testing Guide: Understanding Cybersecurity Risks🤖 Google's AI Pivot: Supercharged Assistant📦 Musk's Grid Warning: Invest in Energy Transition🔭 Tool & Article Discovery➡️ The Recommendation of the Week🗣️ The Aphorism of the Week 📢Sponsored by: Mimecast.com - Protect yourself against vulnerabilities with an added layer of security 📢Sponsored by: Panoptica.app - Simplify container deployment, monitoring, and securityBecome a Member: https://danielmiessler.com/upgradeSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

10 Elo 202330min

NO. 392 — Trail of Bits Testing Handbook, Startups Freefall, and Chinese Propaganda Escalation…

NO. 392 — Trail of Bits Testing Handbook, Startups Freefall, and Chinese Propaganda Escalation…

In this episode: 💡 Burnout and Addiction: A New Perspective🚦 UL RSS Live: Stay Updated🔍 Security News: Testing Handbook, IDOR Vulnerability, Lazarus Hacks📈 Technology News: Startup Decline, iPhone Dominance, AI Girlfriends🌍 Human News: Longevity Habits, Unemployment Rates, Math Crisis💭 Ideas & Analysis: AI Tooling and Reading🎨 Hacker Art by Rez0🛠️ Discovery: New Tools and Insights👥 Managerial Pitfalls: Transitioning Roles👜 Birkin Bag Economics: The World's Most Expensive Handbag🔭 Tool & Article Discovery➡️ The Recommendation of the Week🗣️ The Aphorism of the Week 📢Sponsored by: Mimecast.com - Protect yourself against vulnerabilities with an added layer of security 📢Sponsored by: Panoptica.app - Simplify container deployment, monitoring, and securityBecome a Member: https://danielmiessler.com/upgradeSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

31 Heinä 202318min

NO. 391 — AI Manipulation Defenders, .MIL Leak, And The NPC Phenomenon

NO. 391 — AI Manipulation Defenders, .MIL Leak, And The NPC Phenomenon

In this episode: 🤖 How AI Will Defenders Protect Us📈 AI's Role in K-Shaped Recovery📧 Military Email Leak🔐 VirusTotal Data Leak🇨🇳 Great Firewall Expansion🍏 Apple vs UK Surveillance🚗 TikTok Theft Tutorials👁️ AI Surveillance Expansion🔧 Tech Scam Evolution🤖 OpenAI's Persistent Context🍏 Apple's AI Chatbot📰 AI Journalism🔭 Tool & Article Discovery➡️ The Recommendation of the Week🗣️ The Aphorism of the Week 📢Sponsored by: Moonlock.com - understand how Mac users navigate the increasingly complex security landscape 📢Sponsored by: Mimecast.com - Protect yourself against vulnerabilities with an added layer of securityBecome a Member: https://danielmiessler.com/upgradeSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

24 Heinä 202322min

NO. 390 — Voice Scams, FrontView Mirrors, and Idea Molecules

NO. 390 — Voice Scams, FrontView Mirrors, and Idea Molecules

In this episode: 🚨 VoiceFake Scams on the Rise🔑 FrontView Mirror, 2024 Edition: Trends and Preparations🎙️ AI and Content Creation: A Discussion on The Phillip Wylie Show🔒 Chinese Email Hack: A Sophisticated Espionage Effort🌐 Transatlantic Data Flow: A New EU-US Data Privacy Framework🔍 Docker Security Flaws: Sensitive Data in Docker Images🏥 HCA Healthcare Breach: Impacting 11 Million Patients⚖️ Orca Suing Wiz: A Case of Patent Infringement🤖 AI-Enabled Cybercrime: The Rise of WormGPT🐦 Twitter Struggles: Ad Revenue Plummets by Nearly 50%🎵 TikTok Music Launches: A New Competitor for Apple Music and SpotifyBecome a Member: https://danielmiessler.com/upgradeSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

17 Heinä 202320min

NO. 389 — The Creativity Friction Coefficient, Lockbit v TSMC, and Detecting Smart Errors

NO. 389 — The Creativity Friction Coefficient, Lockbit v TSMC, and Detecting Smart Errors

📚 The Real Internet of Things: A Look into the Future of Technology🔒 Pentera's Unique Approach to Automated Security Validation🌐 AI and the Reduction of the Creativity Friction Coefficient🔐 LockBit vs. TSMC: A Tale of Ransomware and Supply Chain Dependencies☁️ The US's Move to Block Chinese Cloud Usage: A National Security Matter🔥 Fortinet Fallout: A Critical Bug in FortiGate Firewalls🇨🇳 New Chinese APT Tradecraft: Volt Typhoon's Stealthy Approach🔍 Google's Privacy Policy Update: Feeding the AI🌞 Solar Hacking: The Exposure of Renewable Energy Units📋 And more… Sponsor: https://pentera.io Become a Member: https://danielmiessler.com/upgradeSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

10 Heinä 202318min

Sponsored Interview: Pentera

Sponsored Interview: Pentera

Alright, in this Sponsored Interview I’m talking with Aviv Cohen. Aviv is an engineer turned Chief Marketing Officer with Pentera, so if he sounds more technical than most CMOs, that’s why. We talk about Pentera’s Automated Security Validation platform, which he says is similar but different to automated pen testing and attack surface management, and we discuss multiple dimensions of that, from the space they play in, the problem with existing solutions, and a lot more. And with that, there’s my conversation with Aviv Cohen. https://pentera.io Become a Member: https://danielmiessler.com/upgradeSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

10 Heinä 202346min

NO. 388 — Context Reflections, Critical Thinking, China's Decline, and NFC

NO. 388 — Context Reflections, Critical Thinking, China's Decline, and NFC

In this episode: 📚 Using Reflections to Compress LLM Context Data 🎧 My Appearance on the Critical Thinking Podcast 🍏 Apple's Critical Security Updates ⌚ Suspicious Smartwatches Targeting Military Personnel 🔥 Databricks Acquires Generative AI Company 🌐 Cloudflare's Observatory Performance Monitoring Tool 📺 LG Integrates AirPlay 2 and HomeKit into Hotel TVs 💼 Remote Work as a Competitive Advantage for Small Tech Companies 🐝 Beehiiv Raises $12.5 Million 🔍 AI Zoom Magic by Midjourney 🇨🇳 China's Economic Countdown? 🧠 Illusion of Moral Decline 📸 Smartphone Domination in Photography 💡 The Worst Intellectual Trait: NFC 🌍 Climate Change vs. Familial Self-preservation Instincts 🚢 Titanic Belief and Ignoring DangerBecome a Member: https://danielmiessler.com/upgradeSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

26 Kesä 202316min