Talking John - Episode 34: "What Is Truth?"

Episode 34 - What Is Truth?

Scripture: John 18:1-40

Description: This chapter is filled with failures of leadership.In some instances, it seems as though people are making decisions to preserve their own power. In others, it may be to keep those with more power than them from crushing down upon them. What do you think is behind the actions of Annas, Caiaphas, and Pilate? Are they after truth or just privilege?

Questions to consider if you are using this podcast for study:

1. “What is truth?” Pilate’s question echoes through history. Do you hear it as cynical, confused, or sincere? How do you personally wrestle with defining or discerning truth in your life?
2. In this chapter, Jesus seems to assert control even in the face of arrest and judgment. How does John's portrayal of Jesus as calm and commanding shape your understanding of divine power?
3. When Jesus says “I am he” and the crowd falls back, it is seen as a culmination of all the “I am” statements in John. What does this moment tell you about Jesus' identity and mission?
4. Peter’s denials are presented without mention of his weeping in John’s Gospel. Do you see this as an omission of mercy, or as a critique? How do we hold space for both failure and grace in our own lives?
5. Much of the narrative focuses on people trying to avoid responsibility (Pilate, Peter, the crowd). Where are we tempted to do the same today? How can we recognize and resist those moments?
6. The podcast contrasts the Synoptics’ portrayal of Jesus’ agony with John’s portrayal of exaltation. How do both perspectives deepen your understanding of Jesus’ humanity and divinity?
7. Even amid betrayal, denial, and political games, Jesus chooses the path of sacrificial love. How does this challenge or inspire your own capacity to love, forgive, and serve?