123. Legitimate Criticism? How To Find Out (With A Real World Example)
Decoding Narcissism, Manipulation And Toxic Ideas, with Frederik Ribersson30 Elo 2025

123. Legitimate Criticism? How To Find Out (With A Real World Example)

How can we tell if criticism is legitimate? Let's take a comment left on this podcast to see how we can test criticism to take onboard anything worthwhile, and avoid low level thinking / toxicity masquerading as legitimate criticism.


In short:

- consider "if this is true, what else would have to be true"

- are those things true, or not?

- what is the person actually saying?

- are they attacking a person, or ideas?

- does it display the symptoms of cognitive dissonance?


In a recent episode, I described how one person hijacked a meeting of expats, turned it into a "let's crap on Sweden" event, how some people played along, others were really uncomfortable - and how she bragged about blackmailing people.


But according to one listener, I "just didn't like that she worked with immigrants".


Hm, maybe. Or maybe not.


Let's break down the logic in that criticism to discern whether:

a. it's fair

b. the person finds the behaviour I described is not toxic, but healthy (?!) and it's impossible for lawyers to be toxic.


Given my appreciation of other lawyers who are not blackmailers, my gut feeling is b. But just to be sure, let's check.


This episode is not about an ill-thought snarky comment, but rather how we can take "what appears to be legitimate criticism", and scrutinise it using logic and method. So we can identify bad faith actors and fuzzy thinking.

Tämä jakso on lisätty Podme-palveluun avoimen RSS-syötteen kautta eikä se ole Podmen omaa tuotantoa. Siksi jakso saattaa sisältää mainontaa.

Jaksot(118)

134. Decoding HOAXES And How Narcissists Use Them

134. Decoding HOAXES And How Narcissists Use Them

Smear campaigns are hoaxes. Hoax specialist Mark joins us to explain hoaxes, how they work - and how to recognise them. We discuss the psychology, the levers, how they hack our minds, and how they are...

1 Maalis 1h 45min

133. Sitting With Discomfort Is A Challenge

133. Sitting With Discomfort Is A Challenge

After a breakup, it is normal to feel some discomfort, and it can be challenging to sit with it. Instead, we might be tempted to numb ourselves, find coping mechanisms. But maybe sitting through it en...

20 Helmi 19min

132. Is It Me? When A Group Goes Weird

132. Is It Me? When A Group Goes Weird

From one day to the next, a whole group of people goes weird. But no one says anything. Are we just imagining things? Maybe we did something wrong? So how can we decode this? In this case, a listener ...

20 Joulu 202538min

131. Using Emotions To Navigate (Toxic) Relationships

131. Using Emotions To Navigate (Toxic) Relationships

Learn how to use emotions to detect toxic signals in a relationship, symptoms of unhealthy relationships, and noticing when something is off. As well as reducing the risk a relationship becomes toxic....

22 Marras 202542min

130. Getting Our Energy (And Lives) Back

130. Getting Our Energy (And Lives) Back

Toxic relationships are draining. And managing our energy is crucial in order to get our lives back. I share some thoughts and tips around this, while taking you for a walk - and hoping the noise is n...

17 Marras 202516min

129. How To Trust Again After A Narcissist?

129. How To Trust Again After A Narcissist?

After we trusted too easily, too much the wrong person, what do we do? Shutting down and no longer trusting anyone is safe. But... It leads to a very lonely life, and might be a bit of an overreaction...

16 Marras 202525min

128. Picking Up On Toxic Signals In Real Time - Real Story

128. Picking Up On Toxic Signals In Real Time - Real Story

I noticed a series of strange signals before things get really weird - but I reacted calmly: I was prepared, this time. I'd started speaking with a woman at the hotel gym. I noticed some weird comment...

26 Loka 202541min

127. Reputation Destruction (Smear Campaign): Decoding, Debunking and Managing A Toxic Ex Colleague

127. Reputation Destruction (Smear Campaign): Decoding, Debunking and Managing A Toxic Ex Colleague

A friend was upset: he's fallen out with an ex colleague, whom I happen to know. He was worried because of a former "colleague" who was smearing him. I happen to know the guy, and found him weird.In t...

18 Loka 202523min

Suosittua kategoriassa Yhteiskunta

olipa-kerran-otsikko
seitseman
siita-on-vaikea-puhua
i-dont-like-mondays
sita
poks
antin-palautepalvelu
kaksi-aitia
mamma-mia
hupiklubi
gogin-ja-janin-maailmanhistoria
yopuolen-tarinoita-2
ihme-ja-kumma
kolme-kaannekohtaa
rss-palmujen-varjoissa
mystista
meidan-pitais-puhua
aikalisa
rss-haudattu
loukussa