#198: Estimation vs the punitive target
Better ROI from Software Development15 Tammi 2025

#198: Estimation vs the punitive target

This episode is part of a wider mini-series looking at Estimation in Software Development.

In this episode, I wanted to highlight the emotional baggage that you developers may associate with estimation, and through no fault of your own, will carry that baggage into future estimation work.

In the episode, I look at the psychological scarring left behind from decades of using estimates as punitive targets.

Like most experienced developers, I've worked in organisations that turn estimates into punitive targets - where a well-meaning estimate has been turned into a commitment, and ultimately, a stick to beat the team with.

Now that stick has ranged from the aggressive to the passive, be it threats of dismissal or simply discussing the failure to hit the estimate.

-----

Find this episodes show notes at: https://red-folder.com/podcasts/198

Have an idea for an episode topic, or want to see what is coming up: https://red-folder.com/podcasts/roadmap


Jaksot(206)

#197: Estimation vs Dependencies

#197: Estimation vs Dependencies

This episode is part of a wider mini-series looking at Estimation in Software Development. In this episode, I wanted to look at the impact that dependencies have on software estimation. This episode w...

8 Tammi 202510min

#196: Estimation vs Planning

#196: Estimation vs Planning

This episode is part of a wider mini-series looking at Estimation in Software Development. In this episode, I want to encourage you to mentally separate estimation and planning. They are often confla...

18 Joulu 20249min

#195: Estimation - An estimate by any other name

#195: Estimation - An estimate by any other name

This episode is part of a wider mini-series looking at Estimation in Software Development. In last week's episode, I asked you to think about what the term "estimate" means to you, your team and your ...

11 Joulu 202412min

#194: Estimation - What are you actually asking for?

#194: Estimation - What are you actually asking for?

This episode is part of a wider mini-series looking at Estimation in Software Development. In this week's episode, I want to discuss what the term "estimate" may mean to you and the colleagues that yo...

4 Joulu 202416min

#193: Estimation - How much to invest

#193: Estimation - How much to invest

This episode is part of a wider mini-series looking at Estimation in Software Development. In this episode I want to take a deeper dive into the cost of achieving that - what is the correct cost for t...

27 Marras 202414min

#192: Estimation - Predictability vs Optimism

#192: Estimation - Predictability vs Optimism

This episode is part of a wider mini-series looking at Estimation in Software Development. In the last episode, I talk about the short hand of a "valuable estimate" -  an estimate that is desirable fo...

20 Marras 202414min

#191: Estimation - what is a valuable estimate?

#191: Estimation - what is a valuable estimate?

This episode is part of a wider mini-series looking at Estimation in Software Development. So for this episode I want to introduce the idea of a "valuable estimate" and what that may mean for you. As ...

13 Marras 202414min

#190: Estimation - Do you get value?

#190: Estimation - Do you get value?

I started the mini-series in episode 189 by providing the following guidelines: Don't invest in estimates unless there are clear demonstrable value in having them Agree what a "valuable" estimate l...

6 Marras 202418min