Andy Gullahorn: The Art of the Unexpected

This week on The Pivot, we’re joined by our long-time friend, the incredibly talented musician and songwriter, Andy Gullahorn. While Andy is still a full-time musician—a career he’s passionately pursued for years—he’s approaching it in wonderfully different ways. We dive into the stories behind his fantastic new record, Winning Streak, and how his unique approach to songwriting often includes those signature left hooks that can make you laugh and cry in the same breath. Andy shares insights into the unexpected circuit of his career, from playing music at intensive therapy retreats where he now co-leads small groups, to the hilarious and heartfelt origins of “grinching” (yes, it involves Christmas trees and a U-Haul), and the enduring tradition of the hi-five with his friend Gabe. We also learn about the joy of Silent Bob Euchre, a card game played in public places without speaking—a testament to Andy’s belief in the power of silly, shared experiences. Join us for a truly fun conversation that explores how Andy finds depth, connection, and even a bit of performance art in both his music and his wonderfully unconventional life.

Thought-Provoking Quotes:

“I played the same stage after it was abandoned for thirty years, but that’s the kind of stuff people leave off of their bio—the second half of the sentence. But I have shared the stage with the Spice Girls.” - Andy Gullahorn

“I’ve always loved playing songs for people in the context of their life. I don’t really like getting in and leaving without knowing where I am.” - Andy Gullahorn

“We called it grinching because it felt like you were shoving a Christmas tree up a chimney when you were trying to shove it into a Sienna. And then we would literally play ‘You’re A Mean One, Mr. Grinch’ on repeat in the car.” - Andy Gullahhorn

“If there’s something ridiculous you can do that is not harming anybody and some people are going to look at it and be like, ‘I don't understand it. That's weird.’ To me, it’s like a little art piece in the world. I try to collect that as much as I can.” - Andy Gullahorn

Links, Products, and Resources Mentioned:

Andy Gullahorn’s new record, Winning Streak

Winning Streak (Vinyl + CD) - SIGNED OVERPAY - Andy Gullahorn

“I Saw a Stranger With Your Hair” by John Gorka

David Wilcox (musician)

Pierce Pettis (musician)

“The Chair” by George Strait

Surfing for God by Mike Cusick

Guest’s Links

Andy Gullahorn’s website

Andy Gullahorn’s Facebook

Andy Gullahorn’s Instagram

Andy Gullahorn’s X

Andy Gullahorn’s YouTube

*Watch this interview on the YouTube channel!

*All episode music is by Andrew Osenga.

Connect with Andrew:

Website

YouTube

Substack

Spotify

Facebook

Instagram

How to Remember by Andrew Osenga

Hold the Light by Andrew Osenga

*The Pivot is produced in conjunction with Four Eyes Media.