That's Spooky

How many licks does it take 'til you get to the center of this mystery? This week, Tyler and Johnny discuss the alien encounters of David Huggins and the strange legacy of the Blackburn Cult. Plus: he...

29 Touko 20191h 43min

Time to clean the jam off of your hands! This week, Tyler and Johnny discuss the murder of Cassie Jo Stoddart and the legend of Resurrection Mary. Plus: a possible explanation for ghosts, queens every...

22 Touko 20191h 27min

Call up your best frenemy! This week, Johnny and Tyler discuss the murder of Angel Melendez (the 'Party Monster' case) and the Great Amherst Mystery. Plus: secret attic roommates, getting Suspirious, ...

15 Touko 20191h 26min

Have a happy moving-in day! This week, Johnny and Tyler discuss the creepy story of the Watcher and the case of Bill Allen. Plus: Gaysper the ghost goes viral, buy Aleister Crowley's old house, and a ...

8 Touko 20191h 27min

Hope you like poems! This week Tyler and Johnny discuss the elusive Chupacabra, and one of the biggest wieners of all time, BTK. Plus: the Heavy Metal Knitting Championship, child drag queens, and a l...

1 Touko 20191h 28min

Welcome to the Warrenapalooza! This week, Tyler and Johnny discuss the Smurl Family haunting and the trial of Arne Cheyenne Johnson. Plus: demon dating experiences, remembering Lorraine Warren, and a ...

24 Huhti 20191h 20min

Delicious is a state of mind! This week, Johnny and Tyler discuss the unsolved murder of Dorothy Jane Scott, and the mystery of This Man. Plus: gender reveal party mayhem, Elvira's forgotten sitcom, a...

17 Huhti 20191h 8min

Welcome to ‘Murder He Squealed.’ This week, Johnny and Tyler discuss the case of Estefanía Gutiérrez Lázaro, as well as the crimes of Leopold and Loeb. Plus: why book burnings are passé, a quick Drag ...

10 Huhti 20191h 21min