91. The Stranger (S22E57)
Kurt Money and Kateline discuss the Season 22 episode, "The Stranger," hosted by Keith Morri—Excuse me, I mean, it's a Keith Morrison mystery!!!! Brittany Tavar and her two dogs went missing in July 2010 in St. Augustine, Florida. Is she just a woman out and about? Was it the lady who she choked and hit with a wine bottle? Or was it the drifter roomie who lied about being able to burn DVDs and probably about whether he trimmed his nails regularly? Better listen to find out!
7 Heinä 51min
90. The House in the Woods (S26E25)
Kurt Money and Kateline discuss the 2015 murder of Kelley Clayton orchestrated by her husband Tom Clayton, former hockey star, who was nearby playing poker for his alibi. The two breakdown Dateline's coverage of the case in their episode, "The House in the Woods," hosted by Andrea Canning.
30 Kesä 38min
89. Center of the Storm (Karen Read Verdict)
Kurt Money and Kateline discuss the AC hosted Dateline episode about the Karen Read verdict that aired on Thursday. K$ and KL agree on how John O'Keefe died but disagree THE MOST THEY HAVE EVER DISAGREED ON ANYTHING on the outcome of the trial. Holtheads, this is the DAMPEST episode in the history of the show. Enjoy!! NOTE: We covered this case last October when Dateline originally aired it as, "The Night of the Nor'easter." If you are unfamiliar with this case, go check out that episode now (#54) to get the usual breakdown from us. This episode is a little different from our usual in that it is mostly our reaction to the verdict and new evidence presented in the second trial.
23 Kesä 45min
88. Return to the Early Shift (S27E42)
Kurt Money and Kateline discuss the 2019 episode of Dateline, “Return to the Early Shift,” hosted by Jmank. The pocket-squared all-star covers the death of Michelle Mockbee in Kentucky in 2012. Was it her husband and co-worker, Dan? He did cash in a $400,000 insurance policy and his alibi is simply sleeping. Or….could it be one half of another married couple who also work at the same company? Perhaps…but the funniest part of this Dateline is how there has to be a retrial because the prosecutor and main detective had a secret love affair and also someone rips their pants. It’s a pretty great Vault ep and K$ and KL are excited to break it down!
16 Kesä 46min
87. What Lies Beneath (S23E20)
Kurt Money and Kateline discuss the 2015 episode, "What Lies Beneath," hosted by Murphdog! We tried to watch the repeat they played on Friday but it's still not on Peacock so we went back to the vault for a cold case classic about the murder of Lynne Friend in August of 1994. No body, no witnesses, no DNA, no clues. Will the US Navy be able to help law enforcement reach the depths necessary for closure? This is in Murphdog's hood, Miami baby, so you know he crushes it!
9 Kesä 57min
86. Rear Window (S24E48)
Kurt Money and Kateline discuss the 1954 Alfred Hitchcock classic, Rear Window. Just kidding! We've made a trip to the Vault™ to find an old episode from Season 24, "Rear Window," hosted by Andrea Canning. Hitchcock does get a mention though by AC! This was a blast to talk about and has some classic detective hijinks to get some DNA from a suspect. Four attempts are made! Listen now to find out. Also, zero landlords are talked about in this episode. Kateline is absolutely convinced there are.
2 Kesä 45min
85. Footprints in the Snow (S31E19)
Kurt Money and Kateline discuss the Season 31 banger hosted by the one, the only, DENNIS "MURPHDOG" MURPHY! The two are supremely pumped to have a Dawg ep to discuss and one so good as this, even if it is a repeat and Murphdog hasn't hosted a Dateline since March 15th, 2024. "Footprints in the Snow" is about the disappearance of Jonelle Matthews in Greeley, Colorado, in December, 1984 and the 35-year search for her remains and the person responsible for her death. There are a few possible suspects and while K$ and KL do not see eye to eye on who was arrested for the crime, they 100% agree that Jim Matthews, Jonelle's father, DID NOT DO IT!!! Check out the video version of the podcast dropping on YouTube by Wednesday and check out our Patreon "Aisle H", where for $2 a month you get two exclusive episodes a month on Dateline-adjacent content.
26 Touko 58min
84. The Secrets of the Sliding Door (S33E27)
Kurt Money and Kateline discuss the 2012 Staten Island murder of Simeonette Mapes-Crupi. Was it her husband, Jonathan's sneaker collection that inspired a burglary gone wrong? Or was it the silencing of a witness who saw a gang member murdered across the street? We're not spoiling but we can tell you the murderer went to the only hardware store ever mentioned on Dateline, Home Depot! This episode is not sponsored by Home Depot but it is sponsored by Shakespeare's MacBeth. The Dateline episode discussed is "The Secrets of the Sliding Door" that originally aired on NBC on May 4th, 2025, hosted by Keith Morrison. Check out the video version of this podcast posting on the YouTube page tomorrow! And search "Aisle H" on Patreon to get two bonus episodes a month about Dateline-adjacent content!
19 Touko 41min
