The murder of Billie Jean Reynolds | Ep 222

Skip the banter: 00:06:52 (give or take a min or so depending on ads in beginning) Heather West disappeared in 1987. Her parents’ story kept shifting—until one of her siblings repeated a sick family j...

2 Nov 20251h 6min

Skip the banter: 00:08:21 (give or take a minute depending on ads) Jeanine Nicarico was home sick from school when someone kicked in the front door of her family’s quiet Naperville home. What followed...

26 Okt 20251h 8min

Skip the banter: 00:06:09 (give or take a minute depending on ads) Rachel O’Reilly was a devoted mother, a trusted friend, and someone who did everything right. But on a clear October afternoon, her o...

19 Okt 20251h 7min

Here's a bonus Halloween-themed episode for our listeners. On Halloween night, 1957, Peter Fabiano is gunned down by one final trick-or-treater. Or so it seems. To listen to all three episodes of 'Hal...

18 Okt 202535min

Skip the banter: 00:06:32 (give or take a minute due to ads) On a quiet spring night in 2012, the Cipriano family’s home in Farmington Hills, Michigan became the site of a savage and senseless betraya...

12 Okt 20251h 1min

Skip the banter: 00:05:50 (depends on ads in beginning) It started with a young woman left for dead on the side of a road in Oklahoma, her blue high heel abandoned in the street. But the investigation...

5 Okt 202556min

Skip the banter: 00:04:48 When Kari Baker was found dead in her bed, her husband, a respected Baptist preacher, told police it was a suicide. A typed note, a bottle of sleeping pills, and a tragic his...

28 Sep 20251h

Skip the banter: 00:05:54 (give or take a minute depending on ads in the beginning) When Iana Kasian moved to Los Angeles, she had dreams of a new life, one filled with family, safety, and stability. ...

21 Sep 202556min