Pastor KILLED His Mistress… Then Raised Her Baby in Her Graveyard Home! (Marie Carlson Case)

The Pastor, The Mistress & The Backyard Grave: Solving Marie Carlson’s Unthinkable Murder

What if the man who preached at your church… buried your body in his backyard? Dive into the shocking true crime case of Marie Carlson, the young Florida mother who vanished in 2011 after giving birth to her daughter. Her killer? James Flanders – a trusted Fort Walton Beach pastor and the father of her child.

In this chilling episode, we expose:

• The unholy polyamorous triangle between Marie, Flanders, and his wife Tanya – a secret throuple spiraling into obsession and violence.

• How Flanders confessed to strangling Marie, then buried her beneath his swing set while leading search parties for her.

• The "no-body" nightmare: How detectives cracked the case without physical evidence through cell data, lies, and a pastor’s crumbling facade.

• The twisted custody battle: How Flanders’ wife Tanya gained custody of Marie’s baby after his manslaughter plea deal – raising the child in the home where Marie was buried.

• Rare audio from police warrants and the disturbing confession that sealed Flanders’ fate.

We dissect the forensic breakthroughs, the community betrayal in Fort Walton Beach, and why this unthinkable Florida murder remains one of the most bizarre pastor crimes in true crime history. If you think you’ve heard it all… you haven’t.

True Crime Podcast, Marie Carlson Murder, James Flanders Pastor, Fort Walton Beach Florida Crime, No Body Murder Case, Pastor Kills Mistress, Polyamorous Crime, Secret Affair Murder, Backyard Burial, Florida Cold Case Solved, 2011 Unsolved Mystery, Strangulation Crime, Child Custody After Murder, Tanya Flanders, Obsession Crime, Police Interrogation Tactics, Manslaughter Plea Deal, Hidden Graves, Religious Hypocrisy Crime, Shocking Confessions

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/whispers-of-crime-unsolved-true-crime--6281125/support.

Whispers of Crime: Unsolved True Crime is your go-to true crime podcast for exploring the most chilling unsolved mysteries, cold cases, and murder investigations that continue to baffle experts in 2025. We dive deep into infamous serial killer cases, forensic evidence analysis, and criminal investigations that remain shrouded in mystery.

Our true crime episodes uncover shocking twists, DNA breakthroughs, and the latest investigative leads in cases like the Zodiac Killer, Golden State Killer, Long Island Serial Killer, and other notorious unsolved murders. From missing persons cases to underreported crimes, we shine a light on forgotten mysteries that deserve justice and closure.

Whether you're fascinated by forensic files, criminal psychology, or real-life detective work, Whispers of Crime delivers gripping storytelling with compelling evidence analysis. We explore everything from famous cold cases and police investigations to lesser-known homicides and disappeared persons cases that still haunt families and communities.

Join our community of true crime enthusiasts every Tuesday and Friday at 8 PM for new episodes featuring:

In-depth cold case investigations and breakthrough developments
Serial killer profiles and criminal behavior analysis
Unsolved murder mysteries with exclusive interviews
Missing persons cases and abduction investigations
Forensic science insights and DNA evidence updates
Many oth