The "We Are Thinking About Thinking" Episode

SHOW NOTES:

In this episode of the LDA Podcast, Matt and Clark are joined by longtime friend of the show Kat Koppett for a thoughtful and lively conversation about how we think, learn, and make sense of the world.

The discussion opens with a substantive exchange on whether critical thinking can be taught as a general skill. Matt argues that critical thinking depends on deep domain knowledge rather than generic techniques. Clark challenges this view by drawing on research by Peter Ellerton and earlier work by Valerie Shute and Jeffrey Bonar, exploring the limits and possibilities of instruction and transfer.

To clarify the debate, Matt introduces a shared definition of critical thinking based on Peter Facione’s framework. Kat reinforces the point by noting that people struggle to think critically without relevant information, echoing ideas popularized in The Invisible Gorilla by Christopher Chabris and Daniel Simons.

The conversation then turns to generational differences in thinking. Clark introduces Harold Jarche’s Personal Knowledge Mastery model, which leads to a broader discussion of experience, learning, and whether “digital natives” actually think differently. Hint... they don't exist. They push back on generational myths by highlighting research showing little difference in search strategies across age groups.

The episode closes with Matt reflecting on the enduring influence of developmental psychologist Richard Lerner and his work on human development.

Selected References

• Facione, P. A. (2011). Critical Thinking: What It Is and Why It Counts.

• Ellerton, P. (2022). Thinking Skills and Creativity.

• Shute, V., & Bonar, J. (1986).

• Chabris, C., & Simons, D. The Invisible Gorilla.

• Lerner, R. M. (1976). Concepts and Theories of Human Development.

• Jarche, H. Personal Knowledge Mastery: https://jarche.com/pkm/