Nancy Guthrie Case BOTCHED Or Broken Wide Open? FBI Finds Gloves + Kody Brown’s New Look, JFK Jr’s ‘Love Story’ Gets Trashed. Monday, February 16th, 2026 | Sarah Fraser

In this jam-packed episode, I'm diving into the major breaking news in the Nancy Guthrie case—the FBI finally recovered gloves that could contain DNA from the suspect seen in her home surveillance footage, though this investigation could still take months according to experts, and I'm breaking down the scathing LA Times article that calls out how badly this case was botched from day one with an unsecured crime scene and questionable decisions by Sheriff Nanos. I'm also giving you a personal update on my mom's first full week in senior living as she battles dementia (we made it through with some tears but also some beautiful moments), plus I'm obsessing over the new Hulu series about JFK Jr. and Carolyn Bessette Kennedy, sharing Kody Brown's brand new clean-shaven look from his latest cameo. Timestamps: 00:1:18 - FBI Finds Gloves in Nancy Guthrie Case 00:12:16 - Crime Scene Was Never Secured 00:14:56 - Obama Says Aliens Exist (But Not at Area 51) 00:26:31 - McKayla's Shocking Gummy Commercial 00:22:00 - Sister Wives Tea with Mykelti & Tony Tomorrow ⁠MY Go Big Podcasting⁠ Courses Are ON SALE! Learn to start, monetize, and grow your own podcast. Use code NY20 for 20% OFF all courses **SHOP my Amazon Marketplace - especially if you're looking to get geared-up to start your own Podcast!!!** ⁠https://www.amazon.com/shop/thesarahfrasershow⁠ Show is sponsored by: Forhers.com/tsfs to get a personalized, affordable weight loss plan that gets you Weight Loss by Hers is not available everywhere. Compounded drug products are not approved or evaluated for safety, effectiveness, or quality by the FDA. Prescription required. See website for full details, important safety information, and restrictions. Actual price depends on product and plan purchased ⁠Nutrafol.com⁠ use code TSFS for FREE shipping and $10 off your subscription ⁠Quince.com/tsfs⁠ go to Quince dot com slash tsfs for free shipping on your order and 365-day returns. Now available in Canada, too! WelleCo.com Right now get 15% off The Super Elixir and use code TSFS15 at checkout. Try it for yourself and feel a difference within weeks. First time orders only. Follow me on Instagram/Tiktok: @thesarahfrasershow ***Visit our Sub-Reddit: ⁠reddit.com/r/thesarahfrasershow⁠ for ALL things The Sarah Fraser Show!!!*** Advertise on The Sarah Fraser Show: thesarahfrasershow@gmail.com Got a juicy gossip TIP from your favorite TLC or Bravo show? Email: thesarahfrasershow@gmail.com Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices