Prince Andrew Asks Judge Kaplan To Dismiss Virginia Robert's Lawsuit

Prince Andrew asked U.S. District Judge Lewis A. Kaplan to dismiss the civil lawsuit filed against him by Virginia Giuffre, arguing that the case was legally flawed and barred by prior agreements. His legal team contended that a 2009 settlement Giuffre reached with Jeffrey Epstein included broad release language that shielded other potential defendants — including Andrew — from future claims. They also argued that the complaint failed to state a viable claim under federal sex-trafficking laws, asserting that Andrew had no knowledge of Epstein’s alleged trafficking operation and that Giuffre’s allegations lacked sufficient specificity. Additionally, they challenged the court’s jurisdiction, claiming Andrew’s limited contacts with New York were insufficient to justify the case being heard there.

Judge Kaplan ultimately rejected Andrew’s motion, ruling that the language in the Epstein settlement agreement did not automatically immunize the prince at the dismissal stage and that Giuffre’s complaint plausibly alleged claims under the relevant statutes. Kaplan emphasized that factual disputes — including the meaning and scope of the 2009 release — could not be resolved on a motion to dismiss and would require further proceedings. The ruling allowed the lawsuit to move forward into discovery, increasing pressure on Andrew and leading to intense public scrutiny. Shortly thereafter, the case was resolved through an out-of-court settlement, with Andrew denying wrongdoing but agreeing to a financial settlement and a statement expressing regret for his association with Epstein.

to contact me:

bobbycapucci@protonmail.com

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-epstein-chronicles--5003294/support.

Denne episoden er hentet fra en åpen RSS-feed og er ikke publisert av Podme. Den kan derfor inneholde annonser.

Episoder(1000)

Inside The OIG Interview: The Testimony Of An Unnamed MCC Lieutenant (Part 14) (5/4/26)

The deposition of the unnamed MCC lieutenant reveals not just operational failures, but a striking level of evasiveness that runs throughout the testimony. When pressed on critical details—staffing le...

4 Mai 14min

Inside The OIG Interview: The Testimony Of An Unnamed MCC Lieutenant (Part 13) (5/4/26)

4 Mai 13min

New Mexico Investigators Question Zorro Ranch Staff on Andrew Visits As Probe Expands (5/4/26)

Authorities in New Mexico have expanded their investigation into activity at Jeffrey Epstein’s Zorro Ranch, with a particular focus on visits by Prince Andrew. More than a dozen former employees—inclu...

4 Mai 14min

Barry Josephson, Jeffrey Epstein, and the “Epstein’s Books” Detail in Enchanted (5/4/26)

The controversy centers on a background detail in the 2007 Disney film Enchanted, where a storefront named “Epstein’s Books” appears briefly on screen. On its own, that might be brushed off as coincid...

4 Mai 14min

Leon Botstein Resigns After Review Exposes Years of Contact and Fundraising Links to Epstein (5/4/26)

Leon Botstein announced he would step down as president of Bard College after more than 50 years in the role, with his resignation taking effect June 30, 2026. His departure followed an internal legal...

4 Mai 12min

Mega Edition: How The Deck Was Stacked Against Epstein's Survivors In Florida (5/4/26)

From the very beginning, the prosecution of Jeffrey Epstein was designed to protect him, not punish him. Instead of a normal criminal process, what unfolded in South Florida looked more like a negotia...

4 Mai 1h

Mega Edition: The DOJ Jeffrey Epstein And The CVRA Deception Aimed At Survivors (5/4/26)

The Crime Victims’ Rights Act (CVRA) was meant to guarantee Epstein’s survivors a voice in the legal process, but in practice their rights were ignored during the 2007–2008 non-prosecution agreement b...

4 Mai 40min

Mega Edition: Ghislaine Maxwell And The Application For Bail (5/3/26)

In her motion opposing the government’s request for pretrial detention, Ghislaine Maxwell’s legal team argued that she posed no flight risk and should be granted release on strict conditions. They emp...

4 Mai 43min