Prince Andrew Asks Judge Kaplan To Dismiss Virginia Robert's Lawsuit

Prince Andrew asked U.S. District Judge Lewis A. Kaplan to dismiss the civil lawsuit filed against him by Virginia Giuffre, arguing that the case was legally flawed and barred by prior agreements. His legal team contended that a 2009 settlement Giuffre reached with Jeffrey Epstein included broad release language that shielded other potential defendants — including Andrew — from future claims. They also argued that the complaint failed to state a viable claim under federal sex-trafficking laws, asserting that Andrew had no knowledge of Epstein’s alleged trafficking operation and that Giuffre’s allegations lacked sufficient specificity. Additionally, they challenged the court’s jurisdiction, claiming Andrew’s limited contacts with New York were insufficient to justify the case being heard there.

Judge Kaplan ultimately rejected Andrew’s motion, ruling that the language in the Epstein settlement agreement did not automatically immunize the prince at the dismissal stage and that Giuffre’s complaint plausibly alleged claims under the relevant statutes. Kaplan emphasized that factual disputes — including the meaning and scope of the 2009 release — could not be resolved on a motion to dismiss and would require further proceedings. The ruling allowed the lawsuit to move forward into discovery, increasing pressure on Andrew and leading to intense public scrutiny. Shortly thereafter, the case was resolved through an out-of-court settlement, with Andrew denying wrongdoing but agreeing to a financial settlement and a statement expressing regret for his association with Epstein.

to contact me:

bobbycapucci@protonmail.com

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-epstein-chronicles--5003294/support.

Denne episoden er hentet fra en åpen RSS-feed og er ikke publisert av Podme. Den kan derfor inneholde annonser.

Episoder(1000)

Inside The OIG Interview: The Testimony Of An Unnamed MCC Lieutenant (Part 6) (5/1/26)

The deposition of the unnamed MCC lieutenant reveals not just operational failures, but a striking level of evasiveness that runs throughout the testimony. When pressed on critical details—staffing le...

1 Mai 12min

Columbia’s Admissions Scandal: How Epstein’s Girlfriend Got In—Twice (5/1/26)

New reporting reveals that a senior administrator at Columbia’s College of Dental Medicine played a central role in helping Jeffrey Epstein’s girlfriend, Karyna Shuliak, gain admission to the program—...

1 Mai 17min

From Cellmate to Storyteller: Nicholas Tartaglione And The Claim That Epstein Left A Note (5/1/26)

The claim that Jeffrey Epstein left behind a suicide note rests almost entirely on the word of his former cellmate, Nicholas Tartaglione—a convicted killer serving multiple life sentences. Tartaglione...

1 Mai 15min

Harvard’s Hidden Donor Scandal: How Epstein’s $25K Reached Women’s Rugby Without Disclosure (5/1/26)

Newly released documents reveal that a $25,000 donation tied to Jeffrey Epstein was funneled to Harvard’s women’s rugby team, but the players themselves say they were never informed of the true source...

1 Mai 14min

Mega Edition: The Ghislaine Maxwell Trial And The Sealed Co-Conspirators (5/1/26)

Judge Alison Nathan’s management of the Ghislaine Maxwell trial unsealing process revealed the stark contradictions at the heart of the U.S. judicial system’s approach to the Epstein network—public ac...

1 Mai 49min

Mega Edition: Who Is Haley Robson? (5/1/26)

Haley Robson is one of the earliest known victims of Jeffrey Epstein’s Palm Beach operation, lured into his orbit when she was just sixteen. Like so many others, she says she was approached under the ...

1 Mai 40min

Mega Edition: Why A Truly Independent Epstein Related Special Counsel Is Needed (4/30/26)

The most credible and unbiased path to the truth in the Jeffrey Epstein scandal would be the appointment of a truly independent special counsel with full prosecutorial authority. The core issue isn’t ...

1 Mai 42min

How the Epstein Files Finally Put Prince Andrew on the Witness List

The latest Epstein document release further reinforces how deeply Prince Andrew was entangled in Jeffrey Epstein’s orbit and how aware authorities were of his potential exposure long before public acc...

1 Mai 22min