Nice But Not Kind: The Everyday Harm of Growing Up in a High-Control Religion

Dr. Gina Colvin's "Ordinary Mormon Trauma" — The Framework That Finally Names What Happened to You

"Ordinary Mormon trauma" is not the dramatic incidents. It's the daily, invisible harm of growing up trained to be nice but not kind, obedient but not teachable, disciplined but not emotionally regulated.

Dr. Gina Colvin — former Mormon academic and host of A Thoughtful Faith — identified ordinary Mormon trauma as the everyday experience of living inside a culture that has never resolved its formative pathologies. Jess and Hannah apply her framework to their own childhoods: the contrasts that explain everything (service-oriented but not care-oriented; confident but not integrated; dependable but not safe), the theological contradiction of a church that preaches agency while eliminating it systematically, and how years of daily self-betrayal produce adults who cannot trust their own instincts. This is the episode for people who say "I had a fine Mormon childhood" and still can't figure out why they ended up in therapy.

In this episode: Dr. Gina Colvin's ordinary Mormon trauma framework and the seven contrasts that define it; how LDS theology preaches agency while structurally eliminating it; the difference between service-orientation and genuine care; why decades of self-betrayal produce adults with broken instinct calibration; what it means to have had a "fine" Mormon childhood and still carry significant psychological harm.

Support the show: buymeacoffee.com/postmormonpostmortem

Ad-free listening from $2/month: patreon.com/postmormonpostmortem

TikTok & Instagram: @postmormonpostmortem

postmormonpostmortem.com

New episodes every Sunday at 9 AM — just in time for sacrament meeting.