146: Bartt Felt: Valley of the Gods, Utah
In March of 2018, 46-year-old Bartt Felt was driving from Michigan to Arizona to visit his father. But while passing through a remote stretch of Utah, something went wrong.His ankle monitor last ping...
24 Sep 38min
145: Casey MacPherson and Caleb Guillory, Part 2: Anguilla
Last week, we followed childhood friends Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy and Caleb Guillory to Anguilla, where a New Year’s trip ended in two sudden and deeply mysterious deaths. What first looked like a pos...
17 Sep 28min
144: Casey MacPherson & Caleb Guillory, Part 1
In December 2018, childhood friends Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy and Caleb Guillory were together on the Caribbean island of Anguilla — surrounded by white sand, turquoise water, and people they trusted. ...
10 Sep 30min
143: Hannah Upp, Part 3: St. Thomas Island
Twice, Hannah Upp disappeared. And twice, against incredible odds, she was found alive. After her second disappearance, Hannah moved to St. Thomas in the U.S. Virgin Islands, where she built a new li...
3 Sep 34min
142: Hannah Upp, Part 2: Wheaton, Maryland
Last week, we told you the story of Hannah Upp, a 23-year-old teacher who mysteriously disappeared in New York City in 2008. Nearly three weeks later, Hannah was found alive in New York Harbor with no...
27 Aug 30min
141: Hannah Upp, Part 1: New York City, NY
In the summer of 2008, 23-year-old teacher Hannah Upp was living in New York City when she suddenly vanished.There was no warning, no explanation, and seemingly no reason for Hannah to walk away from ...
20 Aug 35min
140: Mary Frances Gregory: Las Vegas, Nevada
In February of 1978, nineteen-year-old Mary Frances Gregory left Ontario for what was supposed to be a road trip to California. But she never made it.The man traveling with her later said they crossed...
13 Aug 34min
139: Graham Norris Horne: Bracey, Virginia
Graham Norris Horne was 21 years old when he disappeared in rural Virginia. On August 15, 2024, Graham was traveling with a faith-based group when they stopped for gas at a truck stop in Bracey. Acco...
6 Aug 54min
