Close Encounters of the Third Kind vs. E.T. | Movie Death Match

In anticipation of Disclosure Day, Steven Spielberg’s two most beloved alien films face off in the inaugural Filmspotting Movie Death Match. Representing Close Encounters of the Third Kind is Dr. Margaret A. Weitekamp, Chair of Space History at the National Air and Space Museum. Making the case for E.T. the Extra‑Terrestrial is longtime critic and author Jen Chaney. Host Chris Klimek presides.

Which film better captures Spielberg’s vision of alien contact — and his ideas about the nuclear family? Vote at ⁠moviedeathmatch.com⁠.

Movie Death Match is a new Filmspotting podcast that determines which one of a pair of linked movies — each championed by a passionate and highly credentialed advocate — shall be preserved in perpetuity, and which one shall be lost to history. Through opening statements, formal debate rounds, and closing arguments, a single cinematic judge renders an irreversible verdict. One movie survives. One is erased. Listeners may disagree — but there are no appeals.

Intro & Meeting the Advocates (00:00:00-00:04:40)

The Matchup (00:04:41-00:06:21)

Opening Statements (00:06:22-00:10:26)

Rd. 1: The Movies in Their Time (00:10:27-00:28:49)

Rd. 2: The Movies in Our Time (00:28:50-00:45:39)

Rd. 3: The Movies for All Time (00:45:40-01:01:57)

Closing Arguments & The Verdict (01:01:58-01:04:22)

Credits (01:04:23-01:08:40)

***

Follow Chris: Instagram | Bluesky | X

Episoder(173)

Top 5 Kristen Stewart Scenes | Archive

Kristen Stewart is back in theaters with The Wrong Girls, which is an excuse to share our Top 5 KStew Scenes from 2017. Unlock the full archive, Filmspotting Discord, ad‑free + bonus episodes, and mo...

19 Aug 35min

The Last House and Netflix’s Apocalypse Obsession | SVU

It’s all fine and good to be sealed up in a house with Wagner Moura and Greta Lee, but the longer Netflix’s new The Last House keeps us there, the more time Matt and Jordan have for questions about th...

18 Aug 1h 31min

Anyone Can Cook, Pt. 2 — Tony

Matt Johnson’s new biopic Tony sidesteps the infamous Walk Hard trap by narrowing its scope to a single summer that would end up shaping the rest of Anthony Bourdain’s life, but not necessarily defini...

18 Aug 1h 18min

"You owe everything to the movie and nothing to the original" with David Kajganich | The Movie Racket

Screenwriter and producer David Kajganich (Suspiria, Bones and All) joins Michael Phillips to test a provocative rule of adaptation from filmmaker Whit Stillman: "You owe everything to the movie and n...

17 Aug 1h 14min

Marathon Awards | Dissident Cinema

Adam and Josh share their favorite discoveries, performances, and scenes from the recently completed Dissident Cinema Marathon, which included Chaplin’s The Great Dictator, Kurosawa's No Regrets for O...

16 Aug 52min

Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma and The Brink of War | #1076

Jane Schoenbrun’s uncategorizable third feature, Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma, marks the director as among the most assured and provocative filmmakers of their generation. Adam and Josh agree ...

14 Aug 1h 17min

Anyone Can Cook, Pt. 1 — Ratatouille

Anthony Bourdain, whose early experience working in a restaurant kitchen is chronicled in the new biopic Tony, once singled out Ratatouille as Hollywood’s best depiction of working in a restaurant kit...

13 Aug 1h 15min