#61. Challenging the 'ADHD Was Always There' Narrative

ADHD did not expand by accident.In some U.S. states, nearly 1 in 5 boys have been diagnosed. Adult diagnoses continue to rise. The standard explanation is simple: "It was always there — we're just recognizing it now."But genuine medical conditions do not behave this way.In this episode, I trace the historical evolution of ADHD from a rare and severe childhood condition to a lifelong, broadly defined neurodevelopmental diagnosis. We look at the DSM revisions that expanded criteria, the shift from hyperactivity to inattention, and the moment adult self-report became sufficient for diagnosis.More importantly, we examine the forces that benefited from this expansion

Become a Psychobabble Insider and join us Saturday the 28th of March at 3 PM Eastern for a Live Clinical Session on helping men grieve with Tom Golden!

0:00 The Epidemic of ADHD Diagnoses and Medication0:20 Challenging the 'ADHD Was Always There' Narrative1:02 Why Prevalence Data Disproves the 'Always There' Argument1:40 DSM Revisions and Shifting Diagnostic Criteria2:24 ADHD as a Reflection of Institutional Demands2:52 The Intellectual Roots of Psychiatric Diagnosis: Wundt's Lab3:39 Sir George Still's Early Description of 'Abnormal Incapacity' (1902)4:47 From Brain Damage to Dysfunction: Early Diagnostic Evolution5:35 The Baby Boom and the Need for Conformity: Shifting Focus to Hyperactivity6:46 DSM 2 (1968): Hyperkinetic Reaction and Teachers as Gatekeepers7:59 DSM 3 (1980): The Pivotal Shift to Attention Deficit Disorder (ADD)8:58 DSM 4 (1994): Broadening Criteria, Subtypes, and 'Horoscope Questions'10:24 The Dangers of Subtypes, Spectrum Disorders, and Inclusivity in Psychiatry11:15 Institutional Priorities Driving Diagnostic Expansion12:44 DSM 5 (2013): Redefining ADHD as a Lifelong Neurodevelopmental Disorder13:30 Modern Schooling and Affluent Areas: Why This Diagnosis?14:22 Benefits for Parents: Replacing Moral Judgment with Medical Explanations15:52 Benefits for Teachers: Diagnosis as a Recourse for Behavioral Issues16:47 Psychiatry's Quest for Legitimacy and the Role of ADHD17:39 The Pharmaceutical Industry: Amplifying ADHD Diagnosis18:08 The Role of Identity: ADHD as a Path to Redemption and Status19:12 Why ADHD Grew: Solving Multiple Problems for Many Stakeholders20:20 The Origin of Stimulant Medications: War and Addiction21:20 How Stimulant Medications Work (and What They Don't Do)22:31 Non-Stimulant Medications: Mechanisms and Misrepresentation23:58 Withdrawal Effects, Side Effects, and the Dangers of ADHD Medication25:04 The Core Question: Medicalizing Normal Variants

This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit hannahspier.substack.com/subscribe

Denne episoden er hentet fra en åpen RSS-feed og er ikke publisert av Podme. Den kan derfor inneholde annonser.

Episoder(85)

76. Treating the Pathological Female: Why the Current Model Fails

Most treatments for Borderline Personality Disorder focus on emotional dysregulation. The goal is to reduce distress, self-harm, anxiety, and crises. But that misses the mark. In this episode, I argue...

25 Jun 24min

#73. Psychopath or Sociopath? Reacting to Dr. Ramani and Her Anti-Male Bias

What is the real difference between a psychopath, a sociopath, and antisocial personality disorder? In this episode, I respond to Dr. Ramani's claim that "psychopaths are born and sociopaths are made"...

11 Jun 18min

#74. How to Recognize Female Narcissism

In this episode, I break down the red flags of narcissism in women and why female narcissism is often much harder to recognize than male narcissism. Women are taught from very early on to speak the la...

11 Jun 23min

#75. Does Motherhood Make Women Sick?

Postpartum depression is real, and in some cases it can be severe and even dangerous. Mothers who are struggling deserve compassion, support, and proper care. But what happens when a normal, difficult...

11 Jun 14min

#72. Is Feminism an Intrasexual Competitive Strategy? | Dr Dani Sulikowski

Is feminism really a movement for equality or could it be something else entirely? Evolutionary psychologist Dr Dani Sulikowski joins me to discuss if feminism may be best understood as a form of intr...

4 Jun 1h 4min

#71. The 3 Mechanisms Behind Female Grievance

In this episode, I look at the mechanisms behind female grievance culture: externalizing blame, turning victimhood into identity, and rewarding antagonism through therapy-speak and social media. I arg...

1 Jun 18min

#70. How Feminism Changed Women's Psychological Makeup

For decades, feminist literature has claimed that feminist identification is associated with better psychological well-being in women. But what exactly was being measured and did those measures tell u...

25 Mai 20min

#69. Preventing the Pathological Female and the Role Feminism Played

Prevention matters because once these patterns are learned, they are extremely difficult to undo. I am not convinced we can confidently call them curable. This is a practical look at what could make a...

17 Mai 33min