139 | Dorothy Donovan | The Momma's Boy Who Cried Wolf
The three mustaches decide that they're going to solve a crime from Delaware, and there's nothing that will stand in their way. In June of 1991, Charles Holden called the police with one hell of a wil...
24 Sep 1h 7min
138 | Lindsay Clancy | A Sign of the Times
The three mustaches cave to peer pressure and cover the case that has driven the nation to the brink of madness. In January of 2023, Lindsay Clancy took the lives of her three children. The details of...
17 Sep 2h 23min
137 | The Staudte Family | Pastor Sippy's Tip
The three mustaches grab their chemistry sets to help solve a medical mystery in Springfield, Missouri. In 2013, Diane Staudte rushed her 24-year-old daughter, Sarah to the hospital after she came dow...
10 Sep 2h 12min
136 | Andrea Eilber | The DNA Delay
The three mustaches put on their lab coats and grab an extra chromosome for the road as they travel to Michigan to help with some lab work. After Andrea Eilber was murdered in 2011, authorities were q...
3 Sep 1h 9min
135 | Patricia Hall | Notting Guilty
The three mustaches touch up their dating profiles and set the mood lighting to cover a case from the lonely heart ads. When Patricia Hall vanished without a trace, her husband Keith thought he'd neve...
27 Aug 1h 24min
134 | Aimee Willard | Fool Me Once...
The three mustaches tackle a frustrating case out of Pennsylvania that will leave you wondering whether forgiveness is divine, or criminal negligence. When Aimee Willard disappeared in June of 1996, t...
20 Aug 1h 33min
133 | Lisa Nowak | From Houston With Luvs
The three mustaches prepare to slip the surly bonds of Earth and touch the face of God as they cover a case from Cape Canaveral. In February of 2007, Air Force Captain Colleen Shipman narrowly escaped...
13 Aug 1h 35min
132 | Russell Williams | Colonel Underpants
The three mustaches grab a case of Molson's and put on their toques to cover a case from our maple-scented neighbors to the north. In 2010, the death of a woman named Jessica Lloyd kicked off an inves...
6 Aug 1h 52min
