Is Flat Rate Destroying the Auto Repair Industry? | Steve Blanchard

Like the show? Show your support by using our sponsors.

Need to update your shop systems and software? Try Tekmetric HERE

Launch your tool game to the next level with Launch Tech USA! HERE

In this episode, Jeff welcomes veteran technician Steve Blanchard to compare Quebec's hourly-pay system with Ontario's flat-rate model. Steve shares his journey from GM dealerships in Quebec to working in Ontario, explaining how different pay structures affect technician morale, quality, and shop culture. The conversation explores leadership, service advisor processes, warranty work, EV technology, right-to-repair concerns, and why rewarding quality—not just billed hours—creates stronger teams.

Timestamps:

00:00 Incentives Without Flat Rate
00:46 Podcast Introduction and Guest
02:35 Steve's Early Career in Quebec
05:39 Hourly Pay and Seasonal Layoffs
12:20 Why Quebec Doesn't Use Flat Rate
16:48 Moving to Ottawa
21:03 Red Seal Exam and Flat Rate Shock
22:53 Hands-On vs. Written Testing
28:18 How Flat Rate Hurts the Trade
34:41 Comebacks and Bad Incentives
36:37 Warranty Work and Cutting Corners
39:22 Teamwork vs. Competition
39:49 Training Your Replacement
40:34 Gatekeeping in the Shop
42:32 Dispatch Challenges
44:52 Switching to Hyundai
45:48 Hyundai Failures and Shop Politics
49:31 When Flat Rate Becomes a Punishment
51:40 Warranty Repair Blowup
56:09 Free Labor and Employee Loyalty
01:02:27 DIY Repairs and Safety Risks
01:06:17 EVs and Self-Driving Technology
01:10:12 Vehicle Data and Privacy Concerns
01:14:13 Subscription Features and Paywalls
01:16:52 Software Pricing Challenges
01:17:28 Affordable EV Truck Discussion
01:19:51 EV Charging Reality
01:21:00 EV Lockouts and Liability
01:22:37 The Right-to-Repair Debate
01:25:30 Technician Certification Changes
01:27:11 Remote Vehicle Control and Privacy
01:30:25 Flat Rate vs. Hourly Pay
01:32:18 Leadership and Shop Culture
01:40:04 The Role of Service Advisors
01:43:03 Injury, Career Longevity, and Exit Plans
01:44:45 Better Appointment Preparation
01:55:07 Wrap Up and Closing

Follow/Subscribe to the show on social media!
TikTok - https://www.tiktok.com/@jeffcompton7
YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/@TheJadedMechanic
Facebook - https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100091347564232