Hobbes vs. Boyle: Who Decides Scientific Facts?

Episode Overview

In the 1660s, two towering thinkers, Thomas Hobbes and Robert Boyle, clashed over a strange new machine: the air pump. What looked like a technical disagreement about air and vacuum quickly became something much larger.

This episode examines how Boyle's experimental approach and Hobbes's philosophical skepticism shaped the foundations of modern science, and why their dispute still echoes today in debates over expertise, public trust, and the role of scientists in public policy. From the invention of "virtual witnessing" to modern struggles with misinformation, this is a story about how facts become believable, and what happens when trust breaks down.

What You'll Learn

Why experiments alone do not create trust - You'll learn how Boyle's air-pump experiments required not just data, but carefully crafted descriptions and shared norms to make results credible beyond the room where they occurred.
What Hobbes was really worried about - This episode explains why Hobbes objected to experimental science, not because he rejected evidence, but because he feared the political and social consequences of letting small groups "certify reality."
How this 17th-century dispute explains modern science debates - From climate models to medical guidelines, you'll see how today's arguments over evidence, institutions, and public policy replay the same structural tensions Hobbes and Boyle exposed centuries ago.

📚 Resources & Further Reading

Leviathan and the Air‑Pump - Steven Shapin & Simon Schaffer

New Experiments Physico‑Mechanicall, Touching the Spring of the Air - Robert Boyle

Royal Society - History & motto Nullius in verba

Pew Research Center - Public trust in scientists and policy debates (Nov. 2024 report)

Shapin, Steven. "Pump and Circumstance: Robert Boyle's Literary Technology." Social Studies of Science (1984)

🔗 Explore more on our website: mathsciencehistory.com
📚 To buy my book Hypatia: The Sum of Her Life on Amazon, visit https://a.co/d/g3OuP9h

🌍 Let's Connect!
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/mathsciencehistory.bsky.social
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/math.science.history
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/mathsciencehistory
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/math-science-history/
Threads: https://www.threads.com/@math.science.history
Mastodon: https://mathsciencehistory@mathstodon.xyz
YouTube: Math! Science! History! - YouTube
Pinterest: https://www.pinterest.com/mathsciencehistory

🎧 Enjoying the Podcast?

☕ Support the Show: Coffee!! PayPal

Leave a review! It helps more people discover the show!
Share this episode with friends & fellow history buffs!
Subscribe on your favorite podcast platform

Check out our merch: https://www.mathsciencehistory.com/the-store

Music: All music is public domain and has no Copyright and no rights reserved.
Selections from The Little Prince by Lloyd Rodgers

Smooth Piano for Documentaries by Universefield from Pixabay

Background Royalty Free Music - Emotional Piano by NotAIGenerated from Pixabay

Ambiant Clean Piano by Alfarran Basalim from Pixabay

Autumn Vibes by Clavier-Music from Pixabay

Now You Are Here by Sergey Cheremisinov from Pixabay

Until next time, carpe diem!

Denne episoden er hentet fra en åpen RSS-feed og er ikke publisert av Podme. Den kan derfor inneholde annonser.

Episoder(235)

The Library of Alexandria: What Really Happened?

After nearly seven years and more than 200 episodes, this is where I say goodbye to Math! Science! History!. The podcast began with my book Hypatia: The Sum of Her Life and grew into something far bey...

30 Sep 25min

Descartes' Secret Notebook: The Hidden Math Behind Topology

René Descartes is famous for Cogito, ergo sum and his revolutionary approach to philosophy and mathematics. But he also left behind a mysterious 16-page manuscript written in code. In this episode, we...

24 Sep 13min

SCIENCE NEWS TUESDAY: A New Species is Discovered

Scientists have officially identified a new wild cat species in Bolivia and a new snake species from New Guinea—and one of them is named after Guns N' Roses guitarist Slash. But these discoveries are ...

22 Sep 12min

GH Hardy, Ramanujan, The Search For Proof And The Discovery Of Truth

GH Hardy was a character. He had qualities that were odd, yet endearing. He was a rigorous mathematician. Yet, when he received a letter from Srinivasa Ramanujan, he changed. He learned a new way of e...

10 Sep 22min

REPOST The Resilience of Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar

In this episode of Math, Science, History, host Gabrielle Birchak does a repost about Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar, a 19-year-old prodigy whose curiosity during a two-week sea voyage in 1930 led to a gr...

3 Sep 11min

REPOST: When Women Gather

What happens when women gather? Throughout the eighteenth century, women across Europe began creating intellectual communities where they could discuss science, mathematics, philosophy, politics, lite...

27 Aug 17min

FLASHCARDS! Three Lessons from a Tobacco Engineer on Curiosity and Identity

Your job is what you do, not who you are - and that distinction could change your life. Gabrielle Birchak spotlights the astonishing story of Paul Tannery, a daytime engineer in the French tobacco adm...

21 Aug 8min

Paul Tannery: The Tobacco Engineer Who Changed the History of Math

Paul Tannery didn't begin his career intending to become one of the most influential historians of mathematics. He trained as an engineer at the École Polytechnique and spent much of his professional ...

18 Aug 33min