Listen now: Suspect "Five Shots in the Dark"
Leon Benson spent 24 years in an Indiana state prison for the 1998 murder of a young man named Kasey Schoen. His conviction hinged on the testimony of two eyewitnesses – but what if their memories tur...
17 Jul 20235min
EP192: Killer Clown
Marlene Warren loved clowns. She loved them so much, she painted many pictures of clowns, and one of her paintings is our cover photo. Marlene enjoyed clowns so much, that it was an ironic tragedy whe...
17 Jul 202343min
EP191: Lobster Boy
During the early 20th century in the United States, there were traveling carnivals that included sideshows that showcased people with genetic abnormalities. One family who traveled with the carnival, ...
3 Jul 202339min
EP190: Money is the Root of All Evil
Sandra Bridewell was a beautiful woman who seemed to have a lot of tragedy in her life. Her first husband was a victim of suicide, her second husband passed away due to cancer, and her third husband.....
29 Jun 202347min
EP189: Where is Erica Baker?
THANK YOU TO JESS M. AND JENNIFER S. FOR SUGGESTING THIS EPISODE!In February 1999, sweet 9-year-old Erica Baker vanished from her neighborhood in Kettering, Ohio. Kettering was once considered a safe ...
19 Jun 202344min
EP188: The Real Life Buffalo Bill
Remember in "Silence of the Lambs" when we are shown the character, Buffalo Bill and his basement chamber of horrors? Many claim that the character of Buffalo Bill was based on serial killer Gary Heid...
12 Jun 202346min
EP187: The Crimes of Robert Durst
If you lived under a rock in 2015, you probably missed HBO's documentary, "The Jinx" which told the story of mysterious and bizarre deaths that occurred around multi-millionaire, Robert Durst. His fir...
29 Mai 202352min
EP186: The Canal Murderer
John Sweeney seemed like a hard-working and decent man when he married his first wife, Anne in 1976. However, by the time his marriage to Anne ended, John had become a violent drug-abusing alcoholic w...
22 Mai 202344min
