Episode 61: The SOLVED Murder of April Tinsley

Two sisters, 15 year old Barbara and 12 year old Patricia Grimes, disappeared after watching a movie at the Brighton Park Movie Theater in Chicago on December 28, 1956. Less than a month later their n...

5 Feb 202447min

Denise Huskins was abducted while spending the night at her boyfriend’s home in March 2015, but when Aaron Quinn went to report what had happened, he immediately became a suspect. The Vallejo Police D...

1 Feb 20241h 27min

Shemika Cosey was 16-years-old girl when she vanished from Berkeley, Missouri on December 28, 2008, between 1:30 and 8:30 a.m. It was at her aunt's residence, where she had spent the night with her co...

25 Jan 202432min

John Emil List committed the cold-blooded murder of his entire immediate family in his Westfield, New Jersey mansion in 1971. He then evaded authorities for almost 18 years, during which he started an...

22 Jan 202439min

On February 24, 1978, 5 young men from Yuba County, California attended a college basketball game at Chico State, which is a CSU campus in Chico, Ca. The game was about 50 miles away from their hometo...

18 Jan 202445min

Happy New Year, humans!! To kick off the new year we have some hilarious and harrowing tales from you all, so strap in for our 24th installment of listener stories to start 2024! To submit a listener...

15 Jan 202434min

In July 1997, an employee at a Starbucks in Washington D.C. arrived at work to find a horrific scene: the night manager, Mary Mahoney, along with two other employees, Emory Evans and Aaron Goodrich, h...

11 Jan 202434min

On June 13, 2001, 19 year old Jason Jolkowski received a call from his boss at Fazoli’s, an Italian American chain restaurant, asking if he could come into work early. Jason’s car was in the shop, so ...

4 Jan 202433min