Judy Smith

In 2020, a young Amish woman went missing while walking home from church. A combination of eye witnesses and security cameras led the police to the culprit, setting off a string of events that would l...

2 Aug 202146min

When Logan Tucker disappeared, his mother had two stories about where he was--one she gave to family and the other to law enforcement. One thing was clear: neither story was true. But building a case ...

26 Jul 20211h 6min

A woman was gunned down while crossing the street and all evidence pointed in one direction. But could a brilliant, detail oriented person with a PhD be capable of such a sloppy cover up? Yes, yes he ...

19 Jul 202152min

Unlike the majority of male serial killers, female serial killers don’t usually kill from a compulsion to kill but rather for pragmatic reasons. But that doesn’t make the trail of destruction any less...

12 Jul 202152min

In 2003, a couple was gunned down in their own home. Three suspects emerged early on but the investigation would soon focus on one of them. But would the other two alternative suspects be enough for r...

5 Jul 202149min

In 1977, the woman who inherited the Brach’s candy fortune vanished. Inconsistent stories, tales of horse thievery, and a lot of hinky stuff over the last 44 years has left this one an enduring unsolv...

23 Jun 202150min

In 1977, the woman who inherited the Brach’s candy fortune vanished. Inconsistent stories, tales of horse thievery, and a lot of hinky stuff over the last 44 years has left this one an enduring unsolv...

21 Jun 202148min

Thank you to Annie from Fresh Hell for joining me! This is a little bit of a different episode. We recorded this for inclusion in a documentary. To hear more about the case, check out: https://player...

17 Jun 202152min