Jury Instructions on Appeal: When a Few Words Can Change the Outcome

Episode Summary: In this episode of Strategic Justice in Action, host David Senoff, a seasoned plaintiffs attorney, delves into the critical role of jury instructions in the appellate process. Joined by co-host Evan Mack, they explore how incorrect jury instructions can lead to appeals and potentially overturn trial verdicts. David shares insights from his own experiences with insurance bad faith cases and the complexities of drafting jury instructions. The discussion covers the importance of objecting to jury instructions, the intricacies of Pennsylvania's waiver trap, and the appellate court's approach to determining the impact of jury instruction errors on case outcomes. Listeners will gain a deeper understanding of how precise jury instructions can influence the trajectory of a case and the importance of preserving objections for appeal.

Key Timestamps: 00:01 – Introduction 0:20 – Importance of Jury Instructions in Appeals 1:05 – Impact of Incorrect Jury Instructions 2:25 – Drafting Jury Instructions for Breach of Contract 2:52 – Grounds for Appeal Due to Jury Instruction Errors 3:39 – Objecting to Jury Instructions in Pennsylvania 5:05 – Requesting Exceptions to Jury Instructions 7:01 – Correcting Errors in Jury Instruction Delivery 8:47 – Post-Trial Motions and Appeals 9:20 – Appellate Court Review of Jury Instructions 10:38 – Standard vs. Custom Jury Instructions 11:51 – Refusal to Give Requested Jury Instructions 12:58 – Example of Jury Instruction Appeal in Snow and Ice Case 14:55 – Challenging Agreed-Upon Jury Instructions 16:17 – Impact of Incorrect Jury Instructions on Verdict Reversal

About the Show: Strategic Justice in Action is a podcast dedicated to unraveling the complexities of the legal system, particularly focusing on appellate advocacy, insurance, bad faith, and public policy litigation. Hosted by David Senoff, a plaintiffs attorney with extensive experience in holding corporations and governments accountable, the show offers valuable insights into the legal processes that shape significant cases. Each episode provides listeners with practical knowledge and strategies to navigate the legal landscape effectively. Whether you're a legal professional or simply interested in understanding the intricacies of the justice system, Strategic Justice in Action delivers informative and engaging content.

Visit the website below to learn more: https://firstlawstrategy.com/