Sing Sing Prison: Marble Quarry, Electric Chair, and Redemption

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

The phrase "up the river" dates to 1891 and describes a real trip: roughly 30 miles up the Hudson from New York City to Sing Sing. In May 1825, warden Elam Lynds brought a hundred men from Auburn Prison to a 130 acre site in Mount Pleasant that held no walls and no cells, only a marble quarry. The inmates mined the stone and built their own cage under the Auburn system, a regime of total silence enforced by the whip. Their marble also went downriver to build Grace Church and the Lyndhurst Mansion, and the profit made Sing Sing a model prison when it opened in 1826.

This episode follows the long tug of war between punishment and reform that came next. Eliza Farnham handed Dickens novels to the women's ward in 1844. Thomas Mott Osborne tore out a culture of bribes and was indicted for it. Lewis E. Lawes ran the prison for 21 years, building libraries and sports teams while personally overseeing executions he publicly opposed. The story runs through a prison football team sponsored by the owner of the New York Giants to today's theater and college programs, and to plans to turn the original cell block into a museum.

• The name comes from a Native American phrase meaning stone upon stone, which is exactly how the first hundred inmates built the prison.
• From 1891 until 1963, 614 men and women died in the electric chair nicknamed Old Sparky, including Julius and Ethel Rosenberg in 1953 and Eddie Lee Mays, the last person executed in New York State.
• Thomas Mott Osborne spent a week incognito as an inmate at Auburn before becoming warden in 1914, and prisoners threw a jubilant celebration when he returned after his acquittal.
• The Sing Sing Black Sheep played only home games, with ticket revenue going to inmates' families, until the starting quarterback and two other starters escaped on a game morning in 1935.
• Rehabilitation Through the Arts, founded at Sing Sing in 1996, inspired the 2023 film Sing Sing, in which Colman Domingo stars beside program alumnus Clarence Maclin.