196: Got to Be the Black Market Maestro (I (Almost) Got Away With It)

We're tackling the "Idol Worship" episode from Stalked: Someone's Watching so get ready for lots of outlandish singing: A talent show contestant gains a new fan who starts calling her non-stop, turni...

11 Jan 202352min

Welcome listeners, first-time and long-time, to our inaugural episode of I Think Not! We're kicking things off with the harrowing stories of Mary Kay Beckman, Steven Lane, and the toxic people they da...

4 Jan 202357min

Surprise folks! We're bidding farewell to Disappeared with a return to where this podcast started. Enjoy a newly redone version of our pilot with current AND former hosts Ellyn, Joey and Patrick! In ...

21 Des 20221h 13min

When 23-year old Lauryn Garrett vanishes after calling her father for a ride home, the family embark on a journey to find her and uncover startling clues linked to her past. JOIN OUR PATREON! At the ...

14 Des 202256min

The big news has finally arrived people! We're rebranding! Welcome to I Think Not! Give the trailer a listen, and enjoy a description of the new show below: From murder, to crooked cops to tax evasio...

14 Des 20224min

Nancy Moyer disappears while her children are visiting their father. Police look into Moyer's background, finding a surprisingly complicated life. Then, a murder occurs nearby, prompting authorities t...

7 Des 20221h 4min

CALLLING ALLL DDDDDDDDBBBBBBBSSSS!!! TICKETS FOR OBSESSED FEST '23 ARE NOW LIVE!  Join us in Dallas from October 20 - 22! Come mix and mingle with your favorite true crime podcast hosts (seriously, we...

2 Des 20224min

When a retired firefighter goes missing, a bloody crime scene in his garage quickly indicates foul play. However, after a close look, authorities begin to consider the idea of the crime scene being st...

30 Nov 202254min