Episode 180: Sherri Papini - Part 1

This beautiful holiday destination plays host to families looking to relax on its lovely beach. But one pair of kids in the 1970s encountered something far stranger than they could’ve ever expected: a creature with a bizarre appearance, behaving oddly, and then vanishing without a trace. Did they encounter a ghost? A spaceman? Or something far more sinister? Please consider supporting the companies that support us! -Head to factormeals.com/creepy60 to receive 60% off your first box -Go to Zocdoc.com/CREEPY and download the Zocdoc app for free -Visit MyKitsch.com/SINISTER for 30% off your entire order

25 Jan 20231h 18min

Terrifying Tales from Jakarta, Indonesia; LOCK YOUR F****** DOORS!; You will not take me without a fight; A plane, a drone, a helicopter, or a UFO?!!!; and Sexually attractive ghost. Head to sinisterhood.com/freakyfriday to submit your odd but true story

20 Jan 202355min

By this time, women everywhere knew the name Chippendales. Across the globe, studs in cuffs and collars were delighting tons of screaming audiences. But behind the scenes, a different kind of screaming was going on. The owner and the creative director were fighting for control, until one was willing to cross the ultimate line.  Please consider supporting the companies that support us! -This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at betterhelp.com/SINISTER and get on your way to being your best self.

18 Jan 20231h 38min

If you aren't subscribed to our Patreon, we wanted to give you a glimpse of what we've got going on. This mega-mix of clips brings you some of our favorite segments from the month of December. Subscribe today to get full segments plus hundreds of hours of past content. Today you'll hear: Minisode on the Murdaugh Murders Judge Christie rules on a mac 'n cheese dispute AITA: Listener Editions - Turtle Power Judge Christie: Listener Edition - Backpack Beef Don't miss our January events: Live Q&A is Thursday, 1/26 at 2PM CT Livestream is Tuesday, 1/31 at 8PM CT If you like what you hear and want full versions of all this and more, head to patreon.com/sinisterhood for full details on all the benefits to subscribe today!

17 Jan 202336min

My high school years was a Lifetime Movie..; Small Town Texas trauma; College Apartment Intruder; NJ daemon or when paranormal becomes too much; My family was part of the Gothard Brigade; and Looking back with both Chagrin and Compassion - A Cautionary Tale about “Young Love.”  Head to sinisterhood.com/freakyfriday to submit your odd but true story

13 Jan 202351min

Sexy shirtless men in tight pants, cuffs, and collars. The image we have of America’s quintessential male dance revue is sweaty, sexy, glistening men there to fulfill a woman’s fantasy. But behind it all, there was a fully-clothed man hellbent on making millions and willing to do whatever it took to maintain control.   Please consider supporting the companies that support us! -Visit masterclass.com/creepy to get 15% off an annual membership -Helix is offering up to $200 off all mattress orders AND two free pillows for our listeners at Helixsleep.com/creepy

11 Jan 20231h 28min

Mail room interns make a shocking discovery; Edibles and possible trafficking; Have You Heard About Charlie?, Dead Chicken Cult in Chicago?; Ambien Wildin'; and Mom Friend Ghost. Head to sinisterhood.com/freakyfriday to submit your odd but true story

6 Jan 202345min

After tireless efforts from her family, government officials were finally paying attention to what happened to Phoebe Handsjuk. However, her family was soon shocked by the coroner’s official finding. Two journalists put a spotlight on the case, and more attention seemed to be the best way to bring about justice. Please consider supporting the companies that support us!  -This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at betterhelp.com/SINISTER and get on your way to being your best self -Visit MyKitsch.com/SINISTER for 30% off your entire order

4 Jan 20231h 53min