Episode 209: The Murder of Robert Poynter

A beautiful structure meant to guide sailors home safely. A benevolent keeper who gladly hosted soldiers for a drink. But that kindness may have gotten him killed, and left him forever tending the island’s light. Is this just a spooky old building or the eternal home to a restless soul? Tonight’s episode is The Gibraltar Point Lighthouse.  Recorded live at the Royal Theatre in Toronto, CA Click here for info on our tour and to purchase tickets Please consider supporting the companies that support us! -Go to prose.com/CREEPY for your FREE in-depth hair consultation and 15% off your order -Get 15% off both Just Thrive Probiotic and Just Calm or any of their other scientifically proven products, when you go to justthrivehealth.com and use code: CREEPY at checkout -Visit Audible.com/thebiglie to listen to The Big lie with Jon Hamm, created by John Mankiewicz

29 Jun 20222h 6min

The Time I (Kind of) Helped Solve a Murder, Headless Bird, I Was Abducted by Aliens, and They Sent Me Home Without All My Parts, Ummm....Hello From the Other Side?, The Mysterious Case of Our Disappeared Neighbour and Friend :(, and Sasquatches - Lighthearted and No Crying Required. Click here to submit your odd but true story for Freaky Friday Click here for information about our tour and to purchase tickets

25 Jun 202243min

A resident of this central California town captured footage of an unidentifiable creature scurrying across his lawn. He offered the tape to experts and the media who couldn’t determine what this strange monster was. Soon, more sightings were reported across California and beyond. The odd-shaped scampering being didn’t do any harm and was soon embraced as an online phenomenon.  Click here for information on our tour and to purchase tickets! Please consider supporting the companies that support us! -Visit www.smartassandsass.com and use code CREEPY for 15% off your first subscription and shop orders -Visit MyKitsch.com/SINISTER for 30% off your entire order -Go to Zocdoc.com/CREEPY and download the Zocdoc app for free -Sinisterhood is sponsored by BetterHelp. Get 10% off your first month at betterhelp.com/SINISTER

22 Jun 20221h 8min

Zak Bagans Nightmares, My First Time Calling 911, Track Suit Ghost, Nighttime Visitors, Ouija Found My Uncle!, and The Stranger Who Had a Key To My Apartment Click here to submit your odd but true story for Freaky Friday Click here for information about our tour and to purchase tickets

18 Jun 202242min

This gothic structure has attracted filmmakers, history buffs, and paranormal investigators since it began hosting visitors decades ago. What started as a revolutionary state organization crumbled into decay before being saved by passionate citizens. But just as passionate are the former inmates who refuse to leave. Recorded live at Funny Bone in Columbus, Ohio Click here for info on our tour and to purchase tickets Please consider supporting the companies that support us! -Visit Littlepassports.com/CREEPY for 20% off -Visit oliveandjune.com/CREEPY and use code CREEPY for 20% off your first Mani System! This is an exclusive offer you can ONLY get here! -Head to fahertybrand.com/CREEPY and use code CREEPY at checkout to snag 20% off ALL your new Spring staples -Go to prose.com/CREEPY for your FREE in-depth hair consultation and 15% off your order -Head to Outschool.com/CREEPY and use code CREEPY to save $15 on your child's first class

15 Jun 20222h 6min

The day my dad called to ask me why the FBI was looking for me, Appalachian "Not-Deer," The world's worst car thief - A Cautionary Tale, Bad things happen in 3s, Rocky Mountain Witch, and The house that made my mum a believer Click here to submit your odd but true story for Freaky Friday Click here for information about our tour and to purchase tickets

10 Jun 202247min

A shocking crime gripped the community and soon the world. Reporters filled the courtroom to hear the bombshell legal strategy - self-defense. Would their approach work? And even if it did, would justice be served? Please consider supporting the companies that support us! -Helix is offering up to $200 off all mattress orders AND two free pillows for our listeners at Helixsleep.com/creepy -Sinisterhood is sponsored by BetterHelp. Get 10% off your first month at betterhelp.com/SINISTER - Ready to give your brain some TLC? Download Best Fiends FREE today on the App Store or Google Play Click here for information on our tour and to purchase tickets

8 Jun 20221h 22min

Ouija Board "Proof" and early 90s shenanigans, Ghost Cat, My (less than) six degrees of separation from a murderer, The eye in the wall, The house of my dreams, and The lady in the well. Click here to submit your odd but true story for Freaky Friday Click here for information about our tour and to purchase tickets

3 Jun 202240min