What If Social Security Had Been Privatized? The Value of Federal Government Pension Plans

What If Social Security Had Been Privatized? The Value of Federal Government Pension Plans

In 2005, Congress debated giving U.S. workers private savings accounts to invest their Social Security contributions in the stock and bond markets. Sixteen years later, we review how that would have worked out for workers.

Other topics discussed include:

  • How the public and private sectors are both critical for a functioning social security systems
  • Which countries pay the highest social security benefits
  • How have other privatized social security plans worked out around the world
  • How workers prefer defined contribution plans even though they are worse off than if defined benefit plans were still widely available
  • How worried should we be about aging populations and rising dependency ratios
  • Why Social Security won't go away


Sponsors

Madison Trust Self-Directed IRA - Go Here to Learn More and Get Your $100 Off Promo Code

Factor - Use code david50 to get 50% off your meal order

Use this link to post your job for free on LinkedIn Jobs


Insiders Guide Email Newsletter

Get our free Investors' Checklist when you sign up for the free Money for the Rest of Us email newsletter.


Show Notes

Greenspan "There is nothing to prevent the government from creating as much money as it wants."—YouTube

Estimated Financial Effects of the "Social Security Personal Savings Guarantee and Prosperity Act of 2005" by Stephen C. Goss—Social Security Administration

Social Security Quick Calculator—Social Security Administration

The average 401(k) balance by age by Pau Deer—Empower

CBO’s 2022 Long-Term Projections for Social Security—Congressional Budget Office

Policy Basics: Top Ten Facts about Social Security—Center On Budget and Policy Priorities

Evaluation of Four Decades of Pension Privatization in Latin America, 1980-2020: Promises and Reality by Carmelo Mesa-Lago—SSRN

Population Age Structure and Secular Secular Stagnation: The Long Run Evidence by Joseph Kopecky—SSRN

Does Human Capital Compensate for Depopulation? by M. Siskova, Michael Kuhn, Klaus Prettner, Alexia Fürnkranz-Prskawetz—SSRN

How Much Do Public Employees Value Defined Benefit versus Defined Contribution Retirement Benefits? by Oliver Giesecke and Joshua D. Rauh—SSRN

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Episoder(572)

Facing a Financial Squeeze: What Harvard’s Response Can Teach the Rest of Us

Facing a Financial Squeeze: What Harvard’s Response Can Teach the Rest of Us

How can we apply the same emergency measures that Harvard and other universities are using to navigate a financial crisis? Also, how universities invest their endowments and what their performance has...

14 Mai 202525min

Why Bond Investing Is Easier Than Ever

Why Bond Investing Is Easier Than Ever

Discover how bond market ETFs have transformed investing — making bonds easier, cheaper, and more accessible than ever. We also explore how the bond market’s very composition has evolved.Episode Spons...

7 Mai 202526min

Investing in Emerging Markets with Ali Akay

Investing in Emerging Markets with Ali Akay

Ali Akay, CIO of Carrhae Capital, answers why invest in emerging markets. He also shares with Greg Dowling of FEG insights on China, Mexico, South Korea, Argentina, Greece, Turkey, South Korea, and So...

30 Apr 202534min

Is the Rest of the World Selling America?

Is the Rest of the World Selling America?

The U.S has traditionally been a safe haven for investing, but that hasn't been the case in 2025. We explore three economic and narrative regimes and consider why we may be witnessing a shift after 12...

23 Apr 202519min

Where Are We Heading?

Where Are We Heading?

In this episode, we explore what it means to invest in a non-ergodic world—where time, not averages, determines outcomes. We unpack concepts like volatility drag, ensemble vs. time averages, and the i...

16 Apr 202526min

Is This the End of Globalization and Free Trade?

Is This the End of Globalization and Free Trade?

What will the impact be now that the U.S. has one of the highest tariff rates in the world?Topics covered include:Why the Trump administration raised tariffsHow the last round of U.S. tariffs led to h...

9 Apr 202521min

 Is It Too Late to Invest in Gold? with Max Belmont - FEG Insight Bridge

Is It Too Late to Invest in Gold? with Max Belmont - FEG Insight Bridge

Greg Dowling of FEG interviews Max Belmont, a gold specialist and portfolio manager at First Eagle Investments. Greg and Max discuss the historical, philosophical, and practical reasons for owning gol...

2 Apr 202538min

Should You Investment 100% of Your Retirement in Closed-End Funds?

Should You Investment 100% of Your Retirement in Closed-End Funds?

We compare three approaches to closed-end fund investing: Opportunistic trading, the buy and hold income factory, and a systematic approach of selling closed-end funds after 5% gains.We also explore t...

26 Mar 202524min

Populært innen Business og økonomi

stopp-verden
lydartikler-fra-aftenposten
dine-penger-pengeradet
e24-podden
rss-penger-polser-og-politikk
rss-borsmorgen-okonominyhetene
pengepodden-2
livet-pa-veien-med-jan-erik-larssen
pengesnakk
finansredaksjonen
utbytte
morgenkaffen-med-finansavisen
rss-politisk-preik
lederpodden
liberal-halvtime
rss-pa-konto
tid-er-penger-en-podcast-med-peter-warren
stormkast-med-valebrokk-stordalen
rss-sunn-okonomi
rss-markedspuls-2