Episode #125 - The Railroad Killer
John and Daryn discuss a strange case of seemingly unrelated murders across the United States- the victims are different ages, races, and live nowhere near each other. However a unique 'calling card' ...
21 Apr 201942min
Another Shot #50 - You Guys Twins??
John and Daryn discuss a recent bachelorette party, an NYC festival, and answer some gruesome fan questions. Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bartender meet their “big...
18 Apr 201933min
Episode #124 - A Real Life Murder Mystery Dinner
John and Daryn discuss Kimberly Hricko, who found her husband dead under suspicious circumstances, after a romantic date at a murder mystery dinner. Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Dary...
14 Apr 201950min
Another Shot #49 - The 'John's Favorite Things' Edition
John and Daryn discuss movies that have been impactful on their lives, the new Avengers movie, and what being a Spice Girl might be like.Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.co...
11 Apr 201931min
Episode #123 - Rodney Alcala, The Dating Game Killer
John and Daryn discuss the gruesome case of Rodney Alcala, who felt he'd be a great Dating Game candidate in spite of the many women he had tortured to death. Debunk the mystery of what happened when ...
7 Apr 201951min
Another Shot #48 - April Fools!
John and Daryn celebrate April Fools, talk about this year's pranks, and talk about the most influential people in their lives. Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Barten...
4 Apr 201928min
Episode #122 - An Almost Contract Killing
John and Daryn discuss the case of Cynthia Guy, who sought to hire out the ultimate revenge after being spurned by her new husband.Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bar...
31 Mar 201954min
Another Shot #47 - Gramercy Theatre Live Show Recap
John, Daryn, and Matt recap all the crazy and fun events before, during, and after our live show at the Gramercy Theatre. Check out Daryn on Tiny Talk Show! Debunk the mystery of what happened when Jo...
28 Mar 201925min
