S1 Ep19: Not of this Earth
In tonight’s dead letter, we explore a listener’s astonishing story connecting to the infamous USS Nimitz Tic-Tac UFO incident. Mike recounts childhood encounters with doppelgangers and later, his ex...
4 Mar 202539min
S1 Ep18: The Co-Worker's Gift
In tonight’s dead letter, we delve into a truly astonishing story from listener Gus about his daughter Tara. Tara's coworker, on her last shift before college, revealed he could see spirits and descri...
25 Feb 202525min
The Baldoon Mystery with Dr. Rick Fehr
In the fall of 1829, a Scottish settlement was thrown into turmoil by an invisible tormentor whose nightly mischief escalated into arson. Despite constant watch and attempted exorcisms, flames erupted...
23 Feb 20252h 23min
S1 Ep17: Peripheral Presence
Listener Chloe’s Dead Letter starts out talking about the infamous Greyfriars Kirkyard. One of the earliest topics on the main show here at Astonishing Legends. It quickly transitions to her visit to ...
18 Feb 202526min
Seth Breedlove - Small Town Monster
This week, we’re delving into the world of cryptids and unexplained phenomena again with Seth Breedlove, founder of Small Town Monsters. Celebrating 10 years of documenting America’s legends, 2025 pro...
17 Feb 20252h 7min
S1 Ep16: The Underwater Trip
In tonight’s dead letter, Jonathan, a self-described skeptic and psychonaut, recounts his experience taking DMT that led to an encounter with an omniscient entity, sparking a discussion about the natu...
11 Feb 202514min
S1 Ep15: Voices in My Ear
In tonight’s dead letter, listener Nicole recounts a chilling experience of hearing a male voice in her head during a protection ritual. This unsettling event is similar to Tess's experience at the S...
4 Feb 202520min
S1 Ep14: It's Ok Karl
This week's Astonishing Dead Letter Office features a heartwarming story of a benevolent haunting at their family's camp in Gorham, New Hampshire. After the death of listener Karl’s father's friend An...
28 Jan 202510min
